Edit comment LC-2640 for Device and Sensors Working Group

Quick access to LC-2635 LC-2636 LC-2637 LC-2638 LC-2639 LC-2640 LC-2641 LC-2642 LC-2644

Comment LC-2640

Comment Shortname:

Commenter:

On Behalf Of:

Message-id:

Section of the document concerned:

[Free text description]Document as a wholeHTML Media Capture /**/ /*******************************... HTML Media Capture W3C Working Draft 12 July 2012 Abstract The HTML Media Capture specification defines HTML... Status of This Document This section describes the status o... Table of Contents 1. Introduction 2. Conformance 3. Termin... 1. Introduction This section is non-normative. This specifi... 2. Conformance As well as sections marked as non-normative,... user agent 3. Terminology The input element and the HTMLInputElement... input HTMLInputElement File Upload enumerated attribute keyword state invalid value default missing value default capture control type 4. Security and privacy considerations This specification b... 5. The capture attribute This section is normative. When an... partial interface HTMLInputElement { attribute DOMString... 5.1 Attributes capture of type DOMString capture of type DOMString capture camera camcorder microphone filesystem Image Capture Video Capture Sound Capture A. Examples This section is non-normative. The following e... B. References B.1 Normative references [FILE-API] Arun Ra... B.1 Normative references [FILE-API] Arun Ranganathan; Jona... [FILE-API] [HTML5] [RFC2119] [WEBIDL] B.2 Informative references No informative references.
or

Refinement of the section concerned:

Status:

open proposal pending resolved_yes resolved_no resolved_partial other assigned to Nobody Bah, Slimane Bernhart, Bryan Bhaumik, Rijubrata Bogdanovich, Ilya Caceres, Marcos Christiansen, Kenneth DADAS, Mohammed Gouaillard, Alexandre Grant, Reilly Hazaël-Massieux, Dominique Hirsch, Frederick Hu, Ningxin huang, qigang Hwang, Dongseong Jeon, Jonathan Kang, Shin-Gak Kim, Sung Hei Kim, Sunghan Kinlan, Paul Kis, Zoltan Kliche, Ingmar Kollarova, Martina Kostiainen, Anssi Krishnan, Sanjay Lamouri, Mounir Lee, Dong-Young Lee, Kangchan Lee, Seungyun Lee, WonSuk Lin, Wanming Liu, Dapeng Liu, Guanyu Logvinov, Andrey Mandyam, Giridhar McCathie Nevile, Charles Mehrnezhad, Maryam Mikityuk, Alexandra Nilsson, Claes Olejnik, Lukasz Pashidis, Michallis Poussa, Sakari Pozdnyakov, Mikhail Raggett, Dave Scheib, Vincent Shalamov, Alexander Song, Jungkee Spreitzer, Raphael Steglich, Stephan Stojiljkovic, Aleksandar Tran, Dzung Waldron, Rick Walsh, Michael WEI, XIAOHAI xiong, aiden Xue, Fuqiao Yamamoto, Eiji Yamazaki, Fumi Zhang, Rong Zhang, Zhiqiang zhong, heng

Type: substantive editorial typo question general comment undefined

Resolution status:

Response drafted Resolution implemented Reply sent to commenter

Response status:

No response from Commenter yet Commenter approved disposition Commenter objected to disposition
Commenter's response (URI):

Comment:Editorial... 1. That the capture attribute in HTML can be added in markup (rather than being added as a DOM attribute in script) is not obvious from the text, but only from the example section. It would be helpful to clarify this.

Related issues: (space separated ids)

WG Notes: The specification extends the input element's File Upload state, which is defined in HTML5. In order to be consistent with the HTML5 spec, this spec also specifies the extensions in terms of the DOM. Here's the relevant HTML5 reference: [[ Since DOM trees are used as the way to represent HTML documents when they are processed and presented by implementations (especially interactive implementations like Web browsers), this specification is mostly phrased in terms of DOM trees, instead of the markup described above. http://dev.w3.org/html5/spec/introduction.html#a-quick-introduction-to-html ]] Use of the input element is shown in the examples in Appendix A

Resolution: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-device-apis/2012Dec/0022.html We addressed this in a number of places (for formatted version of quoted text see draft link below): Introduction: "The HTML Media Capture specification enables web page authors to declaratively specify the upload of audio, video and still images by adding a new attribute to the HTML input element." Terminology: "The input element, HTMLInputElement interface, accept attribute, and File Upload state are defined in [HTML5]." This indicates that input is an HTML element. Examples: Examples 1,2,3 show declarative form without requiring Javascript; example 4 shows use of markup without form and examples 5-7 show how this can be processed. http://dev.w3.org/2009/dap/camera/

(Please make sure the resolution is adapted for public consumption)

Check to confirm deletion (not reversible)