w3c/wbs-design
or
by mail to sysreq
.
The results of this questionnaire are available to anybody. In addition, answers are sent to the following email addresses: team-wcag-act-surveys@w3.org,maryjom@us.ibm.com,wilco.fiers@deque.com
This questionnaire was open from 2020-12-02 to 2021-01-07.
6 answers have been received.
Jump to results for question:
Review the rule Element with lang attribute has valid language tag which updated to resolve Issue 431. Answer the questions in this survey.
If there are issues with the rule, you may either open an issue in GitHub or provide details in the entry fields for the applicable question.
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results |
Responder | Instructions |
---|---|
Detlev Fischer | |
Wilco Fiers | |
Kathy Eng | |
Trevor Bostic | |
Levon Spradlin | |
Mary Jo Mueller |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes | 6 |
No. I have opened an issue in GitHub or have documented my comments below. | |
I don't know. My questions are documented below. |
Responder | Consistency with ACT Rules Format | Comments |
---|---|---|
Detlev Fischer | Yes | |
Wilco Fiers | Yes | |
Kathy Eng | Yes | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes | |
Levon Spradlin | Yes | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes | 6 |
No. I have opened an issue in GitHub or have documented my comments below. | |
I don't know. My questions are documented below. |
Responder | Rule assumptions | Comments |
---|---|---|
Detlev Fischer | Yes | |
Wilco Fiers | Yes | |
Kathy Eng | Yes | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes | |
Levon Spradlin | Yes | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes | 6 |
No. I have opened an issue in GitHub or have documented my comments below. | |
I don't know. My questions or comments are documented below. |
Responder | Implementation data | Comments |
---|---|---|
Detlev Fischer | Yes | |
Wilco Fiers | Yes | |
Kathy Eng | Yes | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes | |
Levon Spradlin | Yes | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes | 5 |
No. I have opened an issue in GitHub or have documented my comments below. | |
I don't know. My questions or comments are documented below. |
(1 response didn't contain an answer to this question)
Responder | Consistent with accessibility requirements | Comments |
---|---|---|
Detlev Fischer | ||
Wilco Fiers | Yes | |
Kathy Eng | Yes | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes | |
Levon Spradlin | Yes | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes there are open issues that need to be resolved. I have listed them below. | |
Yes, there are open issues but they don't need to be resolved for the rule to be published. | 3 |
No, there are no open issues. | 3 |
Responder | Remaining open issues | Comments |
---|---|---|
Detlev Fischer | No, there are no open issues. | |
Wilco Fiers | Yes, there are open issues but they don't need to be resolved for the rule to be published. | Anne opened this issue a few weeks back. Don't think it's essential to resolve this: https://github.com/act-rules/act-rules.github.io/issues/1499 |
Kathy Eng | Yes, there are open issues but they don't need to be resolved for the rule to be published. | https://github.com/act-rules/act-rules.github.io/issues/1499 |
Trevor Bostic | No, there are no open issues. | |
Levon Spradlin | No, there are no open issues. | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes, there are open issues but they don't need to be resolved for the rule to be published. | There are 3 open issues: 1525 (https://github.com/act-rules/act-rules.github.io/issues/1525), 1520 (https://github.com/act-rules/act-rules.github.io/issues/1520), and 1499 (https://github.com/act-rules/act-rules.github.io/issues/1499). Not sure if any of these are required to be fixed prior to publishing. |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes, I have questions or concerns, described below. | 1 |
No, I have no further questions or concerns. | 5 |
Responder | Other questions or concerns | Comments |
---|---|---|
Detlev Fischer | No, I have no further questions or concerns. | |
Wilco Fiers | No, I have no further questions or concerns. | |
Kathy Eng | Yes, I have questions or concerns, described below. | Does the applicability include alt= value? For example, an English page with an image of French words, with alt in French Also, can the Description be shortened to This rule checks that a non-empty lang attribute of an element in the page body has a valid primary language subtag. |
Trevor Bostic | No, I have no further questions or concerns. | |
Levon Spradlin | No, I have no further questions or concerns. | |
Mary Jo Mueller | No, I have no further questions or concerns. | I do like Kathy's change in the description. She also brings up an interesting question. Is there a way to mark up alt text with a lang tag? |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes, all information is up-to-date. | 6 |
No, it needs the following changes. | |
I don't know, but I have the following concerns. |
Responder | Rule is up-to-date | Comments |
---|---|---|
Detlev Fischer | Yes, all information is up-to-date. | |
Wilco Fiers | Yes, all information is up-to-date. | |
Kathy Eng | Yes, all information is up-to-date. | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes, all information is up-to-date. | |
Levon Spradlin | Yes, all information is up-to-date. | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes, all information is up-to-date. |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes, it is ready to publish as-is. | 3 |
Yes, it is ready to publish with the following changes. | 3 |
No, it is not ready to publish and the reason is documented below. |
Responder | Readiness for publishing | Comments |
---|---|---|
Detlev Fischer | Yes, it is ready to publish as-is. | |
Wilco Fiers | Yes, it is ready to publish with the following changes. | I opened a small PR to change the inapplicable examples: https://github.com/act-rules/act-rules.github.io/pull/1519 |
Kathy Eng | Yes, it is ready to publish with the following changes. | #7 comments |
Trevor Bostic | Yes, it is ready to publish as-is. | |
Levon Spradlin | Yes, it is ready to publish as-is. | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes, it is ready to publish with the following changes. | May need small tweaks, depending on the need to fix open issues and Kathy's suggestions. |
The following persons have not answered the questionnaire:
Send an email to all the non-responders.
Compact view of the results / list of email addresses of the responders
WBS home / Questionnaires / WG questionnaires / Answer this questionnaire
w3c/wbs-design
or
by mail to sysreq
.