w3c/wbs-design
or
by mail to sysreq
.
The results of this questionnaire are available to anybody. In addition, answers are sent to the following email addresses: team-wcag-act-surveys@w3.org,maryjom@us.ibm.com,wilco.fiers@deque.com
This questionnaire was open from 2020-11-11 to 2020-12-03.
5 answers have been received.
Jump to results for question:
Review the rule meta element has no refresh delay and answer the questions in this survey.
If there are issues with the rule, you may either open an issue in GitHub or provide details in the entry fields for the applicable question.
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results |
Responder | Instructions |
---|---|
Wilco Fiers | |
Detlev Fischer | |
Kathy Eng | |
Trevor Bostic | |
Mary Jo Mueller |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes | 5 |
No. I have opened an issue in GitHub or have documented my comments below. | |
I don't know. My questions are documented below. |
Responder | Consistency with ACT Rules Format | Comments |
---|---|---|
Wilco Fiers | Yes | |
Detlev Fischer | Yes | |
Kathy Eng | Yes | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes | 5 |
No. I have opened an issue in GitHub or have documented my comments below. | |
I don't know. My questions are documented below. |
Responder | Rule assumptions | Comments |
---|---|---|
Wilco Fiers | Yes | |
Detlev Fischer | Yes | |
Kathy Eng | Yes | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes | 4 |
No. I have opened an issue in GitHub or have documented my comments below. | |
I don't know. My questions or comments are documented below. | 1 |
Responder | Implementation data | Comments |
---|---|---|
Wilco Fiers | Yes | |
Detlev Fischer | Yes | |
Kathy Eng | Yes | |
Trevor Bostic | I don't know. My questions or comments are documented below. | For the inapplicable section, would it be helpful to add a bit more detail to the description on why the content is invalidd instead of repeating "content attribute is invalid and therefore inapplicable" |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes | 5 |
No. I have opened an issue in GitHub or have documented my comments below. | |
I don't know. My questions or comments are documented below. |
Responder | Consistent with accessibility requirements | Comments |
---|---|---|
Wilco Fiers | Yes | |
Detlev Fischer | Yes | |
Kathy Eng | Yes | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes | Saying yes, since it does a good job explaining under which circumstances some examples satisfy (or not) specific criteria. I am wondering if we should include something like the last sentence of the background as a note in the expectation to make it more prominent. |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes there are open issues that need to be resolved. I have listed them below. | |
Yes, there are open issues but they don't need to be resolved for the rule to be published. | 3 |
No, there are no open issues. | 2 |
Responder | Remaining open issues | Comments |
---|---|---|
Wilco Fiers | Yes, there are open issues but they don't need to be resolved for the rule to be published. | this one https://github.com/act-rules/act-rules.github.io/issues/1115 |
Detlev Fischer | No, there are no open issues. | |
Kathy Eng | Yes, there are open issues but they don't need to be resolved for the rule to be published. | https://github.com/act-rules/act-rules.github.io/issues/1115 |
Trevor Bostic | No, there are no open issues. | |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes, there are open issues but they don't need to be resolved for the rule to be published. | Issue 1115 meta element with delay=0 and no redirect causes infinite loop in browser |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes, I have questions or concerns, described below. | 1 |
No, I have no further questions or concerns. | 4 |
Responder | Other questions or concerns | Comments |
---|---|---|
Wilco Fiers | Yes, I have questions or concerns, described below. | It is unclear what in accessibility support works different in different browsers. Would be useful to include that. |
Detlev Fischer | No, I have no further questions or concerns. | |
Kathy Eng | No, I have no further questions or concerns. | |
Trevor Bostic | No, I have no further questions or concerns. | |
Mary Jo Mueller | No, I have no further questions or concerns. |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes, all information is up-to-date. | 3 |
No, it needs the following changes. | 2 |
I don't know, but I have the following concerns. |
Responder | Rule is up-to-date | Comments |
---|---|---|
Wilco Fiers | No, it needs the following changes. | The format is somewhat outdated. The applicability uses actual HTML instead of a more precise description using elements and attribute values, making it unclear whether case sensitivity applies. In expectation "time" is used, and then defined in a note. Notes should not be used to define content. The assumption can be phrased more clearly, and should not refer to a rule as a test. |
Detlev Fischer | Yes, all information is up-to-date. | |
Kathy Eng | Yes, all information is up-to-date. | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes, all information is up-to-date. | |
Mary Jo Mueller | No, it needs the following changes. | Agree with Wilco's comments. |
Choice | All responders |
---|---|
Results | |
Yes, it is ready to publish as-is. | 2 |
Yes, it is ready to publish with the following changes. | 3 |
No, it is not ready to publish and the reason is documented below. |
Responder | Readiness for publishing | Comments |
---|---|---|
Wilco Fiers | Yes, it is ready to publish with the following changes. | Just needs some editorial work. |
Detlev Fischer | Yes, it is ready to publish as-is. | |
Kathy Eng | Yes, it is ready to publish as-is. | |
Trevor Bostic | Yes, it is ready to publish with the following changes. | Possible changes to test case descriptions |
Mary Jo Mueller | Yes, it is ready to publish with the following changes. | Fix some of those editorial issues brought up and this will be ready to go. |
The following persons have not answered the questionnaire:
Send an email to all the non-responders.
Compact view of the results / list of email addresses of the responders
WBS home / Questionnaires / WG questionnaires / Answer this questionnaire
w3c/wbs-design
or
by mail to sysreq
.