w3c/wbs-design or
by mail to sysreq.
W3C
Site Navigation
Nearby
Results of Questionnaire Miscellaneous Survey for September 8th 2015
The results of this questionnaire are available to anybody.
This questionnaire was open from 2015-09-07 to 2015-10-01.
3 answers have been received.
Jump to results for question:
- Issue 110: Update G65 breadcrumb technique to follow the HTML5 pattern?
- Issue 114: Example #2 of F22 seems to stretch SC 3.2.5 requirement
- Issue 99: Update PDF14 to be in sync with PDF/UA and also ensure footer information is available in other means
1. Issue 110: Update G65 breadcrumb technique to follow the HTML5 pattern?
Please review the following GitHub issue response: Issue 110.
The link above references the specific comment containing the proposal, but feel free to review the discussion within the issue page.
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Accept as proposed | 2 |
| Accept with the following changes | 1 |
| Do not accept at this time |
Details
| Responder | Issue 110: Update G65 breadcrumb technique to follow the HTML5 pattern? | |
|---|---|---|
| Laura Carlson | Accept as proposed | |
| Jonathan Avila | Accept with the following changes | Recommend code indentiom in example for readability |
| Bruce Bailey | Accept as proposed |
2. Issue 114: Example #2 of F22 seems to stretch SC 3.2.5 requirement
Please review the following GitHub issue response: Issue 114.
The link above references the specific comment containing the proposal, but feel free to review the discussion within the issue page.
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Accept as proposed | 3 |
| Accept with the following changes | |
| Do not accept at this time |
Details
| Responder | Issue 114: Example #2 of F22 seems to stretch SC 3.2.5 requirement | |
|---|---|---|
| Laura Carlson | Accept as proposed | |
| Jonathan Avila | Accept as proposed | |
| Bruce Bailey | Accept as proposed |
3. Issue 99: Update PDF14 to be in sync with PDF/UA and also ensure footer information is available in other means
Please review the following GitHub issue response to Issue 99.
The response is found in the pull request for the new technique.
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Accept as proposed | 1 |
| Accept with the following changes | 2 |
| Do not accept at this time |
Details
| Responder | Issue 99: Update PDF14 to be in sync with PDF/UA and also ensure footer information is available in other means | |
|---|---|---|
| Laura Carlson | Accept as proposed | |
| Jonathan Avila | Accept with the following changes | I generally agree but this does not take into account footers/headers that have links. Links cannot be artifacts. |
| Bruce Bailey | Accept with the following changes | I think the final check is hard to parse. If A and B then FAIL==TRUE so FALSE -- but B is written in the negative. So I think it might be easier to parse if B is written in the affirmative: Check on whether the information in the headers and/or footers is available in text or in some other programmatic way in the document. (e.g., on title page, in prose in the main body, PDF pages match header/footer page numbers etc.) If Check 1 is TRUE and Check 2 is FALSE, then this failure condition applies and the content fails the Success Criterion. |
More details on responses
- Laura Carlson: last responded on 8, September 2015 at 12:58 (UTC)
- Jonathan Avila: last responded on 8, September 2015 at 13:17 (UTC)
- Bruce Bailey: last responded on 8, September 2015 at 14:32 (UTC)
Non-responders
The following persons have not answered the questionnaire:
- Gregg Vanderheiden
- Chris Wilson
- Lisa Seeman-Horwitz
- Janina Sajka
- Shawn Lawton Henry
- Katie Haritos-Shea
- Shadi Abou-Zahra
- Chus Garcia
- Steve Faulkner
- Patrick Lauke
- David MacDonald
- Gez Lemon
- Makoto Ueki
- Peter Korn
- Preety Kumar
- Georgios Grigoriadis
- Stefan Schnabel
- Romain Deltour
- Chris Blouch
- Jedi Lin
- Jeanne F Spellman
- Wilco Fiers
- Kimberly Patch
- Glenda Sims
- Ian Pouncey
- Alastair Campbell
- Léonie Watson
- David Sloan
- Mary Jo Mueller
- John Kirkwood
- Detlev Fischer
- Reinaldo Ferraz
- Matt Garrish
- Mike Gifford
- Loïc Martínez Normand
- Mike Pluke
- Justine Pascalides
- Chris Loiselle
- Tzviya Siegman
- Jan McSorley
- Sailesh Panchang
- Cristina Mussinelli
- John Rochford
- Sarah Horton
- Sujasree Kurapati
- Jatin Vaishnav
- Sam Ogami
- Kevin White
- E.A. Draffan
- Paul Bohman
- JaEun Jemma Ku
- 骅 杨
- Victoria Clark
- Avneesh Singh
- Mitchell Evan
- Michael Gower
- biao liu
- Scott McCormack
- Rachael Bradley Montgomery
- Francis Storr
- Rick Johnson
- David Swallow
- Aparna Pasi
- Gregorio Pellegrino
- Melanie Philipp
- Jake Abma
- Nicole Windmann
- Oliver Keim
- Gundula Niemann
- Ruoxi Ran
- Wendy Reid
- Scott O'Hara
- Charles Adams
- Muhammad Saleem
- Amani Ali
- Trevor Bostic
- Jamie Herrera
- Shinya Takami
- Karen Herr
- Kathy Eng
- Cybele Sack
- Audrey Maniez
- Jennifer Delisi
- Arthur Soroken
- Daniel Bjorge
- Kai Recke
- David Fazio
- Daniel Montalvo
- Mario Chacón-Rivas
- Michael Gilbert
- Caryn Pagel
- Achraf Othman
- Helen Burge
- Fernanda Bonnin
- Jared Batterman
- Raja Kushalnagar
- Jan Williams
- Todd Libby
- Isabel Holdsworth
- Julia Chen
- Marcos Franco Murillo
- Yutaka Suzuki
- Azlan Cuttilan
- Jennifer Strickland
- Joe Humbert
- Ben Tillyer
- Charu Pandhi
- Poornima Badhan Subramanian
- Alain Vagner
- Roberto Scano
- Rain Breaw Michaels
- Kun Zhang
- Jaunita George
- Regina Sanchez
- Shawn Thompson
- Thomas Brunet
- Kenny Dunsin
- Jen Goulden
- Mike Beganyi
- Ronny Hendriks
- Olivia Hogan-Stark
- Rashmi Katakwar
- Julie Rawe
- Duff Johnson
- Laura Miller
- Will Creedle
- Shikha Nikhil Dwivedi
- Marie Csanady
- Meenakshi Das
- Perrin Anto
- Rachele DiTullio
- Jan Jaap de Groot
- Rebecca Monteleone
- Ian Kersey
- Peter Bossley
- Anastasia Lanz
- Michael Keane
- Chiara De Martin
- Giacomo Petri
- Andrew Barakat
- Devanshu Chandra
- Xiao (Helen) Zhou
- Joe Lamyman
- Bryan Trogdon
- Mary Ann (MJ) Jawili
- 禹佳 陶
- 锦澄 王
- Stephen James
- Jay Mullen
- Thorsten Katzmann
- Tony Holland
- Kent Boucher
- Abbey Davis
- Phil Day
- Julia Kim
- Michelle Lana
- David Williams
- Mikayla Thompson
- Catherine Droege
- James Edwards
- Eric Hind
- Quintin Balsdon
- Mario Batušić
- David Cox
- Sazzad Mahamud
- Katy Brickley
- Kimberly Sarabia
- Corey Hinshaw
- Ashley Firth
- Daniel Harper-Wain
- Kiara Stewart
- DJ Chase
- Suji Sreerama
- Lori Oakley
- David Middleton
- Alyssa Priddy
- Young Choi
- Nichole Bui
- Julie Romanowski
- Eloisa Guerrero
- Daniel Henderson-Ede
- George Kuan
- YAPING LIN
- Justin Wilson
- Leonard Beasley
- Tiffany Burtin
- Shane Dittmar
- Nayan Padrai
- Niamh Kelly
- Matt Argomaniz Matthew Argomaniz
- Frankie Wolf
- Kimberly McGee
- Ahson Rana
- Carolina Crespo
- humor927 humor927
- Samantha McDaniel
- Matthäus Rojek
- Phong Tony Le
- Bram Janssens
- Graham Ritchie
- Aleksandar Cindrikj
- Jeroen Hulscher
- Alina Vayntrub
- Marco Sabidussi
- John Toles
- Jeanne Erickson Cooley
- Theo Hale
- Gert-Jan Vercauteren
- Karla Rubiano
- Aashutosh K
- Hidde de Vries
- Julian Kittelson-Aldred
- Roland Buss
- Aditya Surendranath
- Avon Kuo
- Elizabeth Patrick
- Tj Squires
- Nat Tarnoff
- Illai Zeevi
- Filippo Zorzi
- Gleidson Ramos
- Mike Pedersen
- Rachael Yomtoob
- Oliver Habersetzer
- Irfan Mukhtar
Send an email to all the non-responders.
Compact view of the results / list of email addresses of the responders
WBS home / Questionnaires / WG questionnaires / Answer this questionnaire
Report issues
on GitHub project