W3C | TAG | Previous: 17 Feb teleconference | Next: 31 Mar 2003 teleconf

Agenda for 24 Mar 2003 TAG teleconference

Nearby: Teleconference details · issues list · www-tag archive

Note: The Chair does not expect the agenda to change after close of business (Boston time) Thursday of this week.

1. Administrative (30min)

1. Confirm Chair, Scribe. Regrets: TBL, CL
2. Accept 17 Feb telecon minutes?
3. Accept this agenda? Proposed to hold 2 hour meeting
4. Next meeting: 31 March?

1.1 Meeting planning

• The TAG will strive to organize a virtual meeting shortly after the WWW Conference.
  Action TBL 2003/03/17: Propose June dates (after 4 June). [Also, some willingness also to meet before May confs]
• Proposed 14-15 Nov Japan
• If confirmed, IJ to ask Member calendar to be updated.
• Upcoming discussions:
  • The TAG expects to discuss its W3C track presentation early-April.
  • The TAG expects to discuss its presentation to the AC mid-April.

1.2 Mailing list management

• Incorporate some proposed text from Stuart Williams into the tips on communicating with the TAG.

  Completed action IJ 2003/03/17: Incorporate said text. Then, action SW: Send msg to www-tag drawing people's attention to revised text. (Done by IJ's message?)

• Create a new list (public-tag-announce) for announcements of meeting minutes, meeting summaries, findings, new issues, resolved issues, and drafts of architecture documents.
  Completed action IJ 2003/03/17: Request list setup; update TAG home page. (Done). PC has requested that list be announced to AC/Chairs/TP list.
• IJ wishes to confirm that (1) all mail goes to www-tag and (2) cc some messages to public-tag-announce

2. Technical (60min)

2.1 New Issues?

• See input from Jonathan Marsh (forwarded by Paul Cotton); related to rdfmsQnameUriMapping-6. See also email from Paul about schema component designators

2.2 Architecture document

See also: findings.

1. 21 Feb 2003 Editor's Draft of Arch Doc:
   1. Action IJ 2003/03/17: Draft a new hybrid that incorporates intro of 6 Feb draft into 21 Feb version.
   2. Action DC 2003/02/06: Attempt a redrafting of 1st para under 2.2.4 of 6 Feb 2003 draft
   3. Action DC 2003/01/27: write two pages on correct and incorrect application of REST to an actual web page design
   4. Action DO 2003/01/27: Please send writings regarding Web services to tag@w3.org. DO grants DC license to cut and paste and put into DC writing.
   5. Action CL 2003/0127: Draft language for arch doc that takes language from internet media type registration, propose for arch doc, include sentiment of TB's second sentence from CP10.
   6. Action TB 2003/01/27: Develop CP11 more: Avoid designing new protocols if you can accomplish what you want with HTTP. DC suggested describing GET/PUT/POST in a para each, then say "if your app looks like that, use HTTP". Proposal from TB to withdraw the proposal.
   7. Action DC 2003/03/17: : Write some text for interactions chapter of arch doc related to message passing, a dual of shared state.
   8. See PC's email on feedback from Tech Plenary; see also minutes of TAG session at Tech Plenary

2.3 Issues the TAG intends to discuss

• IRIEverywhere-27
  • Action CL/IJ 2003/03/17: Send edited piece that CL/MD/IJ wrote to www-tag. Deadline 24 Mar. CL expects at following TAG mtg
• URIEquivalence-15
  • See draft 4. See also email from Larry Masinter on xml namespaces.
  • Completed action TBL 2003/01/20: Send email to uri@w3.org requesting terminology change (regarding definition of "URI"). (Done)
• xmlIDSemantics-32
  • Status of Chris Lilley draft finding in this area? See early snapshot from CL
• contentTypeOverride-24
  • See email from DC to Voice Browser WG. Does this resolve this issue?
• namespaceDocument-8
  • Next steps on RDDL Proposal from Tim Bray/Paul Cotton
• Updates or reports on other issues?

2.4 Issues that have associated action items

• xlinkScope-23
  • Status report?
  • Completed action SW 2003/03/17: Draft note for TAG review of comments to two CGs on the tone of 17 Mar discussion. See draft, and SW message to CG chairs.
• siteData-36
  • Action TBL 2003/02/24 : Summarize siteData-36
• xmlFunctions-34
  • Action TBL 2003/02/06: State the issue with a reference to XML Core work. See email from TimBL capturing some of the issues.
• binaryXML-30
  • Action TB 2003/02/17: Write to www-tag with his thoughts on adding to survey.
  • Next steps to finding? See summary from Chris.
• contentPresentation-26
  • Action CL 2003/02/06: Create a draft finding in this space. Deadline 3 March.
• rdfmsQnameUriMapping-6
  • Action DC 2003/02/06: Propose TAG response to XML Schema desideratum (RQ-23).
• uriMediaType-9
  • Action DC 2003/02/06: Start discussion on discuss@apps.ietf.org, but not urgent
• HTTPSubstrate-16
  • Action RF 2003/02/06: Write a response to IESG asking whether the Web services example in the SOAP 1.2 primer is intended to be excluded from RFC 3205
  • See message from Larry Masinter w.r.t. Web services.
• errorHandling-20
  • Action CL 2003/02/06: Write a draft finding on the topic of (1) early/late detection of errors (2) late/early binding (3) robustness (4) definition of errors (5) recovery once error has been signaled. Deadline first week of March.
• metadataInURI-31
  • Action SW 2003/02/06: Draft finding for this one.
• fragmentInXML-28 : Use of fragment identifiers in XML.
  1. Connection to content negotiation?
  2. Connection to opacity of URIs?
  3. No actions associated / no owner.

3. Other actions

• Action IJ 2003/02/06: Modify issues list to show that actions/pending are orthogonal to decisions. IJ is working with PLH on this. Revisit this end of April.