Pointer Events

Level 3

W3C Working Draft

More details about this document
This version:
https://www.w3.org/TR/2022/WD-pointerevents3-20220629/
Latest published version:
https://www.w3.org/TR/pointerevents3/
Latest editor's draft:
https://w3c.github.io/pointerevents/
History:
https://www.w3.org/standards/history/pointerevents3
Commit history
Test suite:
https://wpt.fyi/pointerevents/
Latest Recommendation:
https://www.w3.org/TR/pointerevents
Editors:
Patrick H. Lauke (TetraLogical)
Navid Zolghadr (Google)
Former editors:
Matt Brubeck (Mozilla)
Rick Byers (Google)
Feedback:
GitHub w3c/pointerevents (pull requests, new issue, open issues)
public-pointer-events@w3.org with subject line [pointerevents3] … message topic … (archives)
Browser support:
caniuse.com

Abstract

The features in this specification extend or modify those found in Pointer Events, a W3C Recommendation that describes events and related interfaces for handling hardware agnostic pointer input from devices including a mouse, pen, touchscreen, etc. For compatibility with existing mouse based content, this specification also describes a mapping to fire Mouse Events for other pointer device types.

Status of This Document

This section describes the status of this document at the time of its publication. A list of current W3C publications and the latest revision of this technical report can be found in the W3C technical reports index at https://www.w3.org/TR/.

This specification is an update to [PointerEvents2] which was shipped broadly by Google Chrome and Microsoft Edge and Mozilla Firefox. Level 3 includes editorial clarifications and new features that facilitate more use cases, in an effort to enable wider developer and browser adoption.

This document was published by the Pointer Events Working Group as a Working Draft using the Recommendation track.

Publication as a Working Draft does not imply endorsement by W3C and its Members.

This is a draft document and may be updated, replaced or obsoleted by other documents at any time. It is inappropriate to cite this document as other than work in progress.

This document was produced by a group operating under the W3C Patent Policy. W3C maintains a public list of any patent disclosures made in connection with the deliverables of the group; that page also includes instructions for disclosing a patent. An individual who has actual knowledge of a patent which the individual believes contains Essential Claim(s) must disclose the information in accordance with section 6 of the W3C Patent Policy.

This document is governed by the 2 November 2021 W3C Process Document.

1. Introduction

This section is non-normative.

Today, most [HTML] content is used with and/or designed for mouse input. Those that handle input in a custom manner typically code to [UIEVENTS] Mouse Events. Newer computing devices today, however, incorporate other forms of input, including touchscreens, pen input, etc. Event types have been proposed for handling each of these forms of input individually. However, that approach often incurs unnecessary duplication of logic and event handling overhead when adding support for a new input type. This often creates a compatibility problem when content is written with only one device type in mind. Additionally, for compatibility with existing mouse-based content, most user agents fire Mouse Events for all input types. This makes it ambiguous whether a Mouse Event represents an actual mouse device or is being produced from another input type for compatibility, which makes it hard to code to both device types simultaneously.

To reduce the cost of coding to multiple input types and also to help with the above described ambiguity with Mouse Events, this specification defines a more abstract form of input, called a pointer. A pointer can be any point of contact on the screen made by a mouse cursor, pen, touch (including multi-touch), or other pointing input device. This model makes it easier to write sites and applications that work well no matter what hardware the user has. For scenarios when device-specific handling is desired, this specification also defines properties for inspecting the device type which produced the event. The primary goal is to provide a single set of events and interfaces that allow for easier authoring for cross-device pointer input while still allowing for device-specific handling only when necessary for an augmented experience.

An additional key goal is to enable multi-threaded user agents to handle direct manipulation actions for panning and zooming (for instance, with a finger or stylus on a touchscreen), without blocking on script execution.

Note

While this specification defines a unified event model for a variety of pointer inputs, this model does not cover other forms of input such as keyboards or keyboard-like interfaces (for instance, a screen reader or similar assistive technology running on a touchscreen-only device, which allows users sequential navigation through focusable controls and elements). While user agents might choose to also generate pointer events in response to these interfaces, this scenario is not covered in this specification.

In the first instance, authors are encouraged to provide equivalent functionality for all forms of input by responding to high-level events such as focus, blur and click. However, when using low-level events (such as Pointer Events), authors are encouraged to ensure that all types of input are supported. In the case of keyboards and keyboard-like interfaces, this might require the addition of explicit keyboard event handling. See WCAG Guideline 2.1 Keyboard Accessible [WCAG21] for further details.

Pointer input combines input from mouse, pen, touch, etc.
Figure 1 A pointer is a hardware agnostic representation of input devices that can target a specific coordinate (or set of coordinates) on a screen.

The events for handling generic pointer input look a lot like those for mouse: pointerdown, pointermove, pointerup, pointerover, pointerout, etc. This facilitates easy content migration from Mouse Events to Pointer Events. Pointer Events provide all the usual properties present in Mouse Events (client coordinates, target element, button states, etc.) in addition to new properties for other forms of input: pressure, contact geometry, tilt, etc. So authors can easily code to Pointer Events to share logic between different input types where it makes sense, and customize for a particular type of input only where necessary to get the best experience.

While Pointer Events are sourced from a variety of input devices, they are not defined as being generated from some other set of device-specific events. While possible and encouraged for compatibility, this spec does not require other device-specific events be supported (e.g. mouse events, touch events, etc.). A user agent could support pointer events without supporting any other device events. For compatibility with content written to mouse-specific events, this specification does provide an optional section describing how to generate compatibility mouse events based on pointer input from devices other than a mouse.

Note

This specification does not provide any advice on the expected behavior of user agents that support both Touch Events (as defined in [TOUCH-EVENTS]) and Pointer Events. For more information on the relationship between these two specifications, see the Touch Events Community Group.

2. Conformance

As well as sections marked as non-normative, all authoring guidelines, diagrams, examples, and notes in this specification are non-normative. Everything else in this specification is normative.

The key words MAY, MUST, MUST NOT, OPTIONAL, and SHOULD in this document are to be interpreted as described in BCP 14 [RFC2119] [RFC8174] when, and only when, they appear in all capitals, as shown here.

3. Examples

This section is non-normative.

The following are basic examples that demonstrate how some of the APIs in this specification might be used by authors. Further, more specific examples are provided in the relevant sections of this document.

Example 1: Feature detection and event binding
/* Bind to either Pointer Events or traditional touch/mouse */

if (window.PointerEvent) {
    // if Pointer Events are supported, only listen to pointer events
    target.addEventListener("pointerdown", function(e) {
        // if necessary, apply separate logic based on e.pointerType
        // for different touch/pen/mouse behavior
        ...
    });
    ...
} else {
    // traditional touch/mouse event handlers
    target.addEventListener('touchstart', function(e) {
        // prevent compatibility mouse events and click
        e.preventDefault();
        ...
    });
    ...
    target.addEventListener('mousedown', ...);
    ...
}

// additional event listeners for keyboard handling
...
Example 2: Detecting the type of input from a user
window.addEventListener("pointerdown", detectInputType);

function detectInputType(event) {
    switch(event.pointerType) {
        case "mouse":
            /* mouse input detected */
            break;
        case "pen":
            /* pen/stylus input detected */
            break;
        case "touch":
            /* touch input detected */
            break;
        default:
            /* pointerType is empty (could not be detected)
            or UA-specific custom type */
    }
}
Example 3: Resizing an element to match the contact geometry
<div style="position:absolute; top:0px; left:0px; width:100px;height:100px;"></div>
<script>
window.addEventListener("pointerdown", checkPointerSize);

function checkPointerSize(event) {
    event.target.style.width = event.width + "px";
    event.target.style.height = event.height + "px";
}
</script>
Example 4: Firing untrusted pointer events from script
const event1 = new PointerEvent("pointerover",
  { bubbles: true,
    cancelable: true,
    composed: true,
    pointerId: 42,
    pointerType: "pen",
    clientX: 300,
    clientY: 500
  });
eventTarget.dispatchEvent(event1);

let pointerEventInitDict =
{
  bubbles: true,
  cancelable: true,
  composed: true,
  pointerId: 42,
  pointerType: "pen",
  clientX: 300,
  clientY: 500,
};
const p1 = new PointerEvent("pointermove", pointerEventInitDict);
pointerEventInitDict.clientX += 10;
const p2 = new PointerEvent("pointermove", pointerEventInitDict);
pointerEventInitDict.coalescedEvents = [p1, p2];
const event2 = new PointerEvent("pointermove", pointerEventInitDict);
eventTarget.dispatchEvent(event2);

4. Pointer Events and interfaces

4.1 PointerEvent interface

WebIDLdictionary PointerEventInit : MouseEventInit {
    long        pointerId = 0;
    double      width = 1;
    double      height = 1;
    float       pressure = 0;
    float       tangentialPressure = 0;
    long        tiltX;
    long        tiltY;
    long        twist = 0;
    double      altitudeAngle;
    double      azimuthAngle;
    DOMString   pointerType = "";
    boolean     isPrimary = false;
    sequence<PointerEvent> coalescedEvents = [];
    sequence<PointerEvent> predictedEvents = [];
};

[Exposed=Window]
interface PointerEvent : MouseEvent {
    constructor(DOMString type, optional PointerEventInit eventInitDict = {});
    readonly        attribute long        pointerId;
    readonly        attribute double      width;
    readonly        attribute double      height;
    readonly        attribute float       pressure;
    readonly        attribute float       tangentialPressure;
    readonly        attribute long        tiltX;
    readonly        attribute long        tiltY;
    readonly        attribute long        twist;
    readonly        attribute double      altitudeAngle;
    readonly        attribute double      azimuthAngle;
    readonly        attribute DOMString   pointerType;
    readonly        attribute boolean     isPrimary;
    [SecureContext] sequence<PointerEvent> getCoalescedEvents();
    sequence<PointerEvent> getPredictedEvents();
};
pointerId

A unique identifier for the pointer causing the event. User agents MAY reserve a generic pointerId value of 0 or 1 for the primary mouse pointer. The pointerId value of -1 MUST be reserved and used to indicate events that were generated by something other than a pointing device. For any other pointers, user agents are free to implement different strategies and approaches in how they assign a pointerId value. However, all active pointers in the top-level browsing context (as defined by [HTML]) must be unique, and the identifier MUST NOT be influenced by any other top-level browsing context (i.e. one top-level browsing context cannot assume that the pointerId of a pointer will be the same when the pointer moves outside of the browsing context and into another top-level browsing context). The user agent MAY recycle previously retired values for pointerId from previous active pointers, or it MAY always reuse the same pointerId for a particular pointing device (for instance, to uniquely identify particular pen/stylus inputs from a specific user in a multi-user collaborative application). However, in the latter case, to minimize the chance of fingerprinting and tracking across different pages or domains, the pointerId MUST only be associated explicitly with that particular pointing device for the lifetime of the page / session, and a new randomized pointerId MUST be chosen the next time that particular pointing device is used again in a new session.

Note

The pointerId selection algorithm is implementation specific. Therefore authors cannot assume values convey any particular meaning other than an identifier for the pointer that is unique from all other active pointers. As an example, user agents may simply assign a number, starting from 0, to any active pointers, in the order that they become active — but these values are not guaranteed to be monotonically increasing.

width

The width (magnitude on the X axis), in CSS pixels (see [CSS21]), of the contact geometry of the pointer. This value MAY be updated on each event for a given pointer. For inputs that typically lack contact geometry (such as a traditional mouse), and in cases where the actual geometry of the input is not detected by the hardware, the user agent MUST return a default value of 1.

height

The height (magnitude on the Y axis), in CSS pixels (see [CSS21]), of the contact geometry of the pointer. This value MAY be updated on each event for a given pointer. For inputs that typically lack contact geometry (such as a traditional mouse), and in cases where the actual geometry of the input is not detected by the hardware, the user agent MUST return a default value of 1.

pressure

The normalized pressure of the pointer input in the range of [0,1], where 0 and 1 represent the minimum and maximum pressure the hardware is capable of detecting, respectively. For hardware and platforms that do not support pressure, the value MUST be 0.5 when in the active buttons state and 0 otherwise. Note: all pointerup events will have pressure 0.

tangentialPressure

The normalized tangential pressure (also known as barrel pressure), typically set by an additional control (e.g. a finger wheel on an airbrush stylus), of the pointer input in the range of [-1,1], where 0 is the neutral position of the control. Note that some hardware may only support positive values in the range of [0,1]. For hardware and platforms that do not support tangential pressure, the value MUST be 0.

tiltX

The plane angle (in degrees, in the range of [-90,90]) between the Y-Z plane and the plane containing both the transducer (e.g. pen/stylus) axis and the Y axis. A positive tiltX is to the right, in the direction of increasing X values. tiltX can be used along with tiltY to represent the tilt away from the normal of a transducer with the digitizer. For hardware and platforms that do not report tilt or angle, the value MUST be 0.

tiltX explanation diagram
Figure 2 Positive tiltX.
tiltY

The plane angle (in degrees, in the range of [-90,90]) between the X-Z plane and the plane containing both the transducer (e.g. pen/stylus) axis and the X axis. A positive tiltY is towards the user, in the direction of increasing Y values. tiltY can be used along with tiltX to represent the tilt away from the normal of a transducer with the digitizer. For hardware and platforms that do not report tilt or angle, the value MUST be 0.

tiltY explanation diagram
Figure 3 Positive tiltY.
twist

The clockwise rotation (in degrees, in the range of [0,359]) of a transducer (e.g. pen/stylus) around its own major axis. For hardware and platforms that do not report twist, the value MUST be 0.

altitudeAngle

The altitude (in radians) of the transducer (e.g. pen/stylus), in the range [0,π/2] — where 0 is parallel to the surface (X-Y plane), and π/2 is perpendicular to the surface. For hardware and platforms that do not report tilt or angle, the value MUST be π/2.

Note
The default value defined here for altitudeAngle is π/2, which positions the transducer as being perpendicular to the surface. This differs from the Touch Events - Level 2 specification's definition for the altitudeAngle property, which has a default value of 0.
altitudeAngle explanation diagram
Figure 4 Example altitudeAngle of π/4 (45 degrees from the X-Y plane).
azimuthAngle

The azimuth angle (in radians) of the transducer (e.g. pen/stylus), in the range [0, 2π] — where 0 represents a transducer whose cap is pointing in the direction of increasing X values (point to "3 o'clock" if looking straight down) on the X-Y plane, and the values progressively increase when going clockwise (π/2 at "6 o'clock", π at "9 o'clock", 3π/2 at "12 o'clock"). When the transducer is perfectly perpendicular to the surface (altitudeAngle of π/2), the value MUST be 0. For hardware and platforms that do not report tilt or angle, the value MUST be 0.

azimuthAngle explanation diagram
Figure 5 Example azimuthAngle of π/6 ("4 o'clock").
pointerType

Indicates the device type that caused the event (mouse, pen, touch, etc.). If the user agent is to fire a pointer event for a mouse, pen/stylus, or touch input device, then the value of pointerType MUST be according to the following table:

Pointer Device TypepointerType Value
Mousemouse
Pen / styluspen
Touch contacttouch

If the device type cannot be detected by the user agent, then the value MUST be an empty string. If the user agent supports pointer device types other than those listed above, the value of pointerType SHOULD be vendor prefixed to avoid conflicting names for different types of devices. Future specifications MAY provide additional normative values for other device types.

Note
See Example 2 for a basic demonstration of how the pointerType can be used. Also note that developers should include some form of default handling to cover user agents that may have implemented their own custom pointerType values and for situations where pointerType is simply an empty string.
isPrimary

Indicates if the pointer represents the primary pointer of this pointer type.

getCoalescedEvents()

A method that returns the list of coalesced events.

getPredictedEvents()

A method that returns the list of predicted events.

The PointerEventInit dictionary is used by the PointerEvent interface's constructor to provide a mechanism by which to construct untrusted (synthetic) pointer events. It inherits from the MouseEventInit dictionary defined in [UIEVENTS]. See the examples for sample code demonstrating how to fire an untrusted pointer event.

The event constructing steps for PointerEvent clones PointerEventInit's coalescedEvents to coalesced events list and clones PointerEventInit's predictedEvents to predicted events list.

Note
The PointerEvent interface inherits from MouseEvent, defined in UI Events. Also note the proposed extension in CSSOM View Module, which changes the various coordinate properties from long to double to allow for fractional coordinates. For user agents that already implement this proposed extension for PointerEvent, but not for regular MouseEvent, there are additional requirements when it comes to the click, auxclick, and contextmenu events.

4.1.1 Button states

4.1.1.1 Chorded button interactions

Some pointer devices, such as mouse or pen, support multiple buttons. In the [UIEVENTS] Mouse Event model, each button press produces a mousedown and mouseup event. To better abstract this hardware difference and simplify cross-device input authoring, Pointer Events do not fire overlapping pointerdown and pointerup events for chorded button presses (depressing an additional button while another button on the pointer device is already depressed).

Instead, chorded button presses can be detected by inspecting changes to the button and buttons properties. The button and buttons properties are inherited from the MouseEvent interface, but with a change in semantics and values, as outlined in the following sections.

The modifications to the button and buttons properties apply only to pointer events. For any compatibility mouse events the value of button and buttons MUST follow [UIEVENTS].

4.1.1.2 The button property

To identify button state transitions in any pointer event (and not just pointerdown and pointerup), the button property indicates the device button whose state change fired the event.

Device Button Changesbutton
Neither buttons nor touch/pen contact changed since last event-1
Left Mouse,
Touch contact,
Pen contact
0
Middle Mouse1
Right Mouse,
Pen barrel button
2
X1 (back) Mouse3
X2 (forward) Mouse4
Pen eraser button5
Note
During a mouse drag, the value of the button property in a pointermove event will be different from that in a mousemove event. For example, while moving the mouse with the right button pressed, the pointermove events will have the button value -1, but the mousemove events will have the button value 2.
4.1.1.3 The buttons property

The buttons property gives the current state of the device buttons as a bitmask (same as in MouseEvent, but with an expanded set of possible values).

Current state of device buttonsbuttons
Mouse moved with no buttons pressed,
Pen moved while hovering with no buttons pressed
0
Left Mouse,
Touch contact,
Pen contact
1
Middle Mouse4
Right Mouse,
Pen barrel button
2
X1 (back) Mouse8
X2 (forward) Mouse16
Pen eraser button32

4.1.2 The primary pointer

In a multi-pointer (e.g. multi-touch) scenario, the isPrimary property is used to identify a master pointer amongst the set of active pointers for each pointer type.

  • At any given time, there can only ever be at most one primary pointer for each pointer type.
  • The first pointer to become active for a particular pointer type (e.g. the first finger to touch the screen in a multi-touch interaction) becomes the primary pointer for that pointer type.
  • Only a primary pointer will produce compatibility mouse events. In the case where there are multiple primary pointers, these pointers will all produce compatibility mouse events.
Note
Authors who desire single-pointer interaction can achieve this by ignoring non-primary pointers (however, see the note below on multiple primary pointers).
Note
When two or more pointer device types are being used concurrently, multiple pointers (one for each pointerType) are considered primary. For example, a touch contact and a mouse cursor moved simultaneously will produce pointers that are both considered primary.
Note
Some devices, operating systems and user agents may ignore the concurrent use of more than one type of pointer input to avoid accidental interactions. For instance, devices that support both touch and pen interactions may ignore touch inputs while the pen is actively being used, to allow users to rest their hand on the touchscreen while using the pen (a feature commonly referred to as "palm rejection"). Currently, it is not possible for authors to suppress this behavior.
Note
In some cases, it is possible for the user agent to fire pointer events in which no pointer is marked as a primary pointer. For instance, when there are multiple active pointers of a particular type, like a multi-touch interaction, and the primary pointer is removed (e.g. it leaves the screen), there may end up being no primary pointers. Also on platforms where the primary pointer is determined using all active pointers of the same type on the device (including those targeted at an application other than the user agent), if the first (primary) pointer is outside of the user agent and other (non-primary) pointers targeted inside the user agent, then the user agent may fire pointer events for the other pointers with a value of false for isPrimary.
Note
Current operating systems and user agents don't usually have a concept of multiple mouse inputs. When more than one mouse device is present (for instance, on a laptop with both a trackpad and an external mouse), all mouse devices are generally treated as a single device — movements on any of the devices are translated to movement of a single mouse pointer, and there is no distinction between button presses on different mouse devices. For this reason, there will usually only be a single mouse pointer, and that pointer will be primary.

4.1.3 Firing events using the PointerEvent interface

To fire a pointer event named e means to fire an event named e using PointerEvent whose attributes are set as defined in PointerEvent Interface and Attributes and Default Actions.

If the event is not gotpointercapture or lostpointercapture, run the process pending pointer capture steps for this PointerEvent.

The target object at which the event is fired is determined as follows:

Let targetDocument be target's node document [DOM].

If the event is pointerdown, pointermove, or pointerup set active document for the event's pointerId to targetDocument.

If the event is pointerdown, the associated device is a direct manipulation device, and the target is an Element, then set pointer capture for this pointerId to the target element as described in implicit pointer capture.

Fire the event to the determined target. The user agent SHOULD treat the target as if the pointing device has moved over it for the purpose of ensuring event ordering [UIEVENTS].

Note
Using the pointer capture target override as the target instead of the normal hit-test result may fire some boundary events, as defined by [UIEVENTS]. This is the same as the pointer leaving its previous target and entering this new capturing target. When the capture is released, the same scenario may happen, as the pointer is leaving the capturing target and entering the hit-test target.
4.1.3.1 Attributes and default actions

The bubbles and cancelable properties and the default actions for the event types defined in this specification appear in the following table. Details of each of these event types are provided in Pointer Event types.

Event TypeBubblesCancelableDefault Action
pointerover Yes Yes None
pointerenter No No None
pointerdown Yes Yes Varies: when the pointer is primary, all default actions of the mousedown event
Canceling this event also prevents subsequent firing of compatibility mouse events.
pointermove Yes Yes Varies: when the pointer is primary, all default actions of mousemove
pointerup Yes Yes Varies: when the pointer is primary, all default actions of mouseup
pointercancel Yes No None
pointerout Yes Yes None
pointerleave No No None
gotpointercapture Yes No None
lostpointercapture Yes No None

Viewport manipulations (panning and zooming) — generally, as a result of a direct manipulation interaction — are intentionally NOT a default action of pointer events, meaning that these behaviors (e.g. panning a page as a result of moving a finger on a touchscreen) cannot be suppressed by canceling a pointer event. Authors must instead use touch-action to explicitly declare the direct manipulation behavior for a region of the document. Removing this dependency on the cancelation of events facilitates performance optimizations by the user agent.

For all pointer events in the table above except pointerenter and pointerleave the composed [DOM] attribute SHOULD be true. For all pointer events in the table above the detail [UIEVENTS] attribute SHOULD be 0.

Note
Many user agents expose non-standard attributes fromElement and toElement in MouseEvents to support legacy content. We encourage those user agents to set the values of those (inherited) attributes in PointerEvents to null to transition authors to the use of standardized alternates (i.e. target and relatedTarget).

Similar to MouseEvent relatedTarget, the relatedTarget should be initialized to the element whose bounds the pointer just left (in the case of a pointerover or pointerenter event) or the element whose bounds the pointer is entering (in the case of a pointerout or pointerleave). For other pointer events, this value will default to null. Note that when an element receives the pointer capture all the following events for that pointer are considered to be inside the boundary of the capturing element.

For gotpointercapture and lostpointercapture all the attributes except the ones defined in the table above should be the same as the Pointer Event that caused the user agent to run the process pending pointer capture steps and fire the gotpointercapture and lostpointercapture events.

4.1.3.2 Process pending pointer capture

The user agent MUST run the following steps when implicitly releasing pointer capture as well as when firing Pointer Events that are not gotpointercapture or lostpointercapture.

  1. If the pointer capture target override for this pointer is set and is not equal to the pending pointer capture target override, then fire a pointer event named lostpointercapture at the pointer capture target override node.
  2. If the pending pointer capture target override for this pointer is set and is not equal to the pointer capture target override, then fire a pointer event named gotpointercapture at the pending pointer capture target override.
  3. Set the pointer capture target override to the pending pointer capture target override, if set. Otherwise, clear the pointer capture target override.
4.1.3.3 Suppressing a pointer event stream

The user agent MUST suppress a pointer event stream when it detects that a pointer is unlikely to continue to produce events. Any of the following scenarios satisfy this condition (there MAY be additional scenarios):

  • The user agent has opened a modal dialog or menu.
  • A pointer input device is physically disconnected, or a hoverable pointer input device (e.g. a hoverable pen/stylus) has left the hover range detectable by the digitizer.
  • The pointer is subsequently used by the user agent to manipulate the page viewport (e.g. panning or zooming). See the section on touch-action CSS property for details.
    Note
    User agents can trigger panning or zooming through multiple pointer types (such as touch and pen), and therefore the start of a pan or zoom action may result in the suppression of various pointers, including pointers with different pointer types.
  • As part of the drag operation initiation algorithm as defined in the drag and drop processing model [HTML], for the pointer that caused the drag operation.
Note

Other scenarios in which the user agent MAY suppress a pointer event stream include:

  • A device's screen orientation is changed while a pointer is active.
  • The user attempts to interact using more simultaneous pointer inputs than the device supports.
  • The user agent interprets the input as accidental (for example, the hardware supports palm rejection).

Methods for detecting any of these scenarios are out of scope for this specification.

The user agent MUST run the following steps to suppress a pointer event stream:

4.2 Pointer Event types

Below are the event types defined in this specification.

In the case of the primary pointer, these events (with the exception of gotpointercapture and lostpointercapture) may also fire compatibility mouse events.

4.2.1 The pointerover event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointerover when a pointing device is moved into the hit test boundaries of an element. Note that setPointerCapture() or releasePointerCapture() might have changed the hit test target. Also note that while a pointer is captured it is considered to be always inside the boundaries of the capturing element for the purpose of firing boundary events. The user agent MUST also fire this event prior to firing a pointerdown event for devices that do not support hover (see pointerdown).

4.2.2 The pointerenter event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointerenter when a pointing device is moved into the hit test boundaries of an element or one of its descendants, including as a result of a pointerdown event from a device that does not support hover (see pointerdown). Note that setPointerCapture() or releasePointerCapture() might have changed the hit test target. Also note that while a pointer is captured it is considered to be always inside the boundaries of the capturing element for the purpose of firing boundary events. This event type is similar to pointerover, but differs in that it does not bubble.

Note
There are similarities between this event type, the mouseenter event described in [UIEVENTS], and the CSS :hover pseudo-class described in [CSS21]. See also the pointerleave event.

4.2.3 The pointerdown event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointerdown when a pointer enters the active buttons state. For mouse, this is when the device transitions from no buttons depressed to at least one button depressed. For touch, this is when physical contact is made with the digitizer. For pen, this is when the pen either makes physical contact with the digitizer without any button depressed, or transitions from no buttons depressed to at least one button depressed while hovering.

Note
For mouse (or other multi-button pointer devices), this means pointerdown and pointerup are not fired for all of the same circumstances as mousedown and mouseup. See chorded buttons for more information.

For input devices that do not support hover, the user agent MUST also fire a pointer event named pointerover followed by a pointer event named pointerenter prior to dispatching the pointerdown event.

Note
Authors can prevent the firing of certain compatibility mouse events by canceling the pointerdown event (if the isPrimary property is true). This sets the PREVENT MOUSE EVENT flag on the pointer. Note, however, that this does not prevent the mouseover, mouseenter, mouseout, or mouseleave events from firing.

4.2.4 The pointermove event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointermove when a pointer changes any properties that don't fire pointerdown or pointerup events. This includes any changes to coordinates, pressure, tangential pressure, tilt, twist, contact geometry (i.e. width and height) or chorded buttons.

User agents MAY delay dispatch of the pointermove event (for instance, for performance reasons). The coalesced events information will be exposed via the getCoalescedEvents() method for the single dispatched pointermove event. The final coordinates of such events should be used for finding the target of the event.

4.2.5 The pointerrawupdate event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointerrawupdate, and only do so within a secure context, when a pointer changes any properties that don't fire pointerdown or pointerup events. See pointermove event for a list of such properties.

In contrast with pointermove, user agents SHOULD dispatch pointerrawupdate events as soon as possible and as frequently as the JavaScript can handle the events.

The target of pointerrawupdate events might be different from the pointermove events due to the fact that pointermove events might get delayed or coalesced, and the final position of the event which is used for finding the target could be different from its coalesced events.

Note that if there is already another pointerrawupdate with the same pointerId that hasn't been dispatched in the event loop, the user agent MAY coalesce the new pointerrawupdate with that event instead of creating a new task. This may cause pointerrawupdate to have coalesced events, and they will all be delivered as coalesced events of one pointerrawupdate event as soon as the event is processed in the event loop. See getCoalescedEvents() for more information.

In terms of ordering of pointerrawupdate and pointermove, if the user agent received an update from the platform that causes both pointerrawupdate and pointermove events, then the user agent MUST dispatch the pointerrawupdate event before the corresponding pointermove.

Other than the target, the concatenation of coalesced events lists of all dispatched pointerrawupdate events since the last pointermove event is the same as the coalesced events of the next pointermove event in terms of the other event attributes. The attributes of pointerrawupdate are mostly the same as pointermove, with the exception of cancelable which MUST be false for pointerrawupdate.

User agents SHOULD not fire compatibility mouse events for pointerrawupdate.

Note
Adding listeners for the pointerrawupdate event might negatively impact the performance of the web page, depending on the implementation of the user agent. For most use cases the other pointerevent types should suffice. A pointerrawupdate listener should only be added if JavaScript needs high frequency events and can handle them just as fast. In these cases, there is probably no need to listen to other types of pointer events.

4.2.6 The pointerup event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointerup when a pointer leaves the active buttons state. For mouse, this is when the device transitions from at least one button depressed to no buttons depressed. For touch, this is when physical contact is removed from the digitizer. For pen, this is when the pen is removed from the physical contact with the digitizer while no button is depressed, or transitions from at least one button depressed to no buttons depressed while hovering.

For input devices that do not support hover, the user agent MUST also fire a pointer event named pointerout followed by a pointer event named pointerleave after dispatching the pointerup event.

The user agent MUST also implicitly release the pointer capture if the pointer is currently captured.

Note
For mouse (or other multi-button pointer devices), this means pointerdown and pointerup are not fired for all of the same circumstances as mousedown and mouseup. See chorded buttons for more information.

4.2.7 The pointercancel event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointercancel when it detects a scenario to suppress a pointer event stream.

4.2.8 The pointerout event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointerout when any of the following occurs:

  • The pointing device is moved out of the hit test boundaries of an element. Note that setPointerCapture() or releasePointerCapture() might have changed the hit test target and while a pointer is captured it is considered to be always inside the boundaries of the capturing element for the purpose of firing boundary events.
  • After firing the pointerup event for a device that does not support hover (see pointerup).
  • The user agent has detected a scenario to suppress a pointer event stream.

4.2.9 The pointerleave event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named pointerleave when any of the following occurs:

  • The pointing device is moved out of the hit test boundaries of an element and all of its descendants. Note that setPointerCapture() or releasePointerCapture() might have changed the hit test target and while a pointer is captured it is considered to be always inside the boundaries of the capturing element for the purpose of firing boundary events.
  • After firing the pointerup event for a device that does not support hover (see pointerup).
  • The user agent has detected a scenario to suppress a pointer event stream.

This event type is similar to pointerout, but differs in that it does not bubble and that it MUST not be fired until the pointing device has left the boundaries of the element and the boundaries of all of its descendants.

Note
There are similarities between this event type, the mouseleave event described in [UIEVENTS], and the CSS :hover pseudo-class described in [CSS21]. See also the pointerenter event.

4.2.10 The gotpointercapture event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named gotpointercapture when an element receives pointer capture. This event is fired at the element that is receiving pointer capture. Subsequent events for that pointer will be fired at this element. See the setting pointer capture and process pending pointer capture sections.

4.2.11 The lostpointercapture event

The user agent MUST fire a pointer event named lostpointercapture after pointer capture is released for a pointer. This event MUST be fired prior to any subsequent events for the pointer after capture was released. This event is fired at the element from which pointer capture was removed. Subsequent events for the pointer follow normal hit testing mechanisms (out of scope for this specification) for determining the event target. See the releasing pointer capture, implicit release of pointer capture, and process pending pointer capture sections.

4.2.12 The click, auxclick, and contextmenu events

This section is an addition to click, auxclick and contextmenu events defined in [UIEVENTS]. The type of these events MUST be PointerEvent, but the dispatch process is going to match that of the original specification.

For these events, all PointerEvent specific attributes (defined in this spec) other than pointerId and pointerType will have their default values. In addition:

  • If the events are generated by a pointing device, their pointerId and pointerType MUST be the same as the PointerEvents that caused these events.
  • If the events are generated by a non-pointing device (such as voice recognition software or a keyboard interaction), pointerId MUST be -1 and pointerType MUST be an empty string.

As noted in PointerEvent, CSSOM View Module proposes to redefine the various coordinate properties (screenX, screenY, pageX, pageY, clientX, clientY, x, y, offsetX, offsetY) as double, to allow for fractional coordinates. However, this change — when applied only to PointerEvent, but not to regular MouseEvent — has proven to lead to web compatibility issues with legacy code in the case of click, auxclick, and contextmenu. For this reason, user agents that have implemented the proposed change in CSSOM View Module only for PointerEvent MUST convert the various coordinate properties for the click, auxclick, and contextmenu to long values (as defined in the original UI Events) using Math.floor [ECMASCRIPT].

5. Extensions to the Element interface

The following section describes extensions to the existing Element interface to facilitate the setting and releasing of pointer capture.

WebIDLpartial interface Element {
  undefined setPointerCapture (long pointerId);
  undefined releasePointerCapture (long pointerId);
  boolean hasPointerCapture (long pointerId);
};
setPointerCapture()

Set pointer capture for the pointer identified by the argument pointerId to the element on which this method is invoked. For subsequent events of the pointer, the capturing target will substitute the normal hit testing result as if the pointer is always over the capturing target, and they MUST always be targeted at this element until capture is released. The pointer MUST be in its active buttons state for this method to be effective, otherwise it fails silently. When the provided method's argument does not match any of the active pointers, throw a "NotFoundError" DOMException.

releasePointerCapture()

Release pointer capture for the pointer identified by the argument pointerId from the element on which this method is invoked. Subsequent events for the pointer follow normal hit testing mechanisms (out of scope for this specification) for determining the event target. When the provided method's argument does not match any of the active pointers, throw a "NotFoundError" DOMException.

hasPointerCapture

Indicates whether the element on which this method is invoked has pointer capture for the pointer identified by the argument pointerId. In particular, returns true if the pending pointer capture target override for pointerId is set to the element on which this method is invoked, and false otherwise.

Note
This method will return true immediately after a call to setPointerCapture(), even though that element will not yet have received a gotpointercapture event. As a result it can be useful for detecting implicit pointer capture from inside of a pointerdown event listener.

6. Extensions to the GlobalEventHandlers mixin

The following section describes extensions to the existing GlobalEventHandlers mixin to facilitate the event handler registration.

WebIDLpartial interface mixin GlobalEventHandlers {
    attribute EventHandler ongotpointercapture;
    attribute EventHandler onlostpointercapture;
    attribute EventHandler onpointerdown;
    attribute EventHandler onpointermove;
    [SecureContext] attribute EventHandler onpointerrawupdate;
    attribute EventHandler onpointerup;
    attribute EventHandler onpointercancel;
    attribute EventHandler onpointerover;
    attribute EventHandler onpointerout;
    attribute EventHandler onpointerenter;
    attribute EventHandler onpointerleave;
};
ongotpointercapture
The event handler IDL attribute for the gotpointercapture event type.
onlostpointercapture
The event handler IDL attribute for the lostpointercapture event type.
onpointerdown
The event handler IDL attribute for the pointerdown event type.
onpointermove
The event handler IDL attribute for the pointermove event type.
onpointerup
The event handler IDL attribute for the pointerup event type.
onpointercancel
The event handler IDL attribute for the pointercancel event type.
onpointerover
The event handler IDL attribute for the pointerover event type.
onpointerout
The event handler IDL attribute for the pointerout event type.
onpointerenter
The event handler IDL attribute for the pointerenter event type.
onpointerleave
The event handler IDL attribute for the pointerleave event type.

7. Extensions to the Navigator interface

The Navigator interface is defined in [HTML]. This specification extends the Navigator interface to provide device detection support.

WebIDLpartial interface Navigator {
    readonly  attribute long maxTouchPoints;
};
maxTouchPoints

The maximum number of simultaneous touch contacts supported by the device. In the case of devices with multiple digitizers (e.g. multiple touchscreens), the value MUST be the maximum of the set of maximum supported contacts by each individual digitizer.

For example, suppose a device has 3 touchscreens, which support 2, 5, and 10 simultaneous touch contacts, respectively. The value of maxTouchPoints should be 10.

Note
While a maxTouchPoints value of greater than 0 indicates the user's device is capable of supporting touch input, it does not necessarily mean the user will use touch input. Authors should be careful to also consider other input modalities that could be present on the system, such as mouse, pen, screen readers, etc.
Note
maxTouchPoints is often used to ensure that the interaction model of the content can be recognized by the current hardware. UI affordances can be provided to users with less capable hardware. On platforms where the precise number of touch points is not known, the minimum number guaranteed to be recognized is provided. Therefore, it is possible for the number of recognized touch points to exceed the value of maxTouchPoints.

8. Declaring direct manipulation behavior

As noted in Attributes and Default Actions, viewport manipulations (panning and zooming) cannot be suppressed by canceling a pointer event. Instead, authors must declaratively define which of these behaviors they want to allow, and which they want to suppress, using the touch-action CSS property.

Note
While the issue of pointers used to manipulate the viewport is generally limited to touch input (where a user's finger can both interact with content and pan/zoom the page), certain user agents may also allow the same types of (direct or indirect) manipulation for other pointer types. For instance, on mobile/tablet devices, users may also be able to scroll using a stylus. While, for historical reasons, the touch-action CSS property defined in this specification appears to refer only to touch inputs, it does in fact apply to all forms of pointer inputs that allow direct manipulation for panning and zooming.

8.1 The touch-action CSS property

Name:touch-action
Value:auto | none | [ [ pan-x | pan-left | pan-right ] || [ pan-y | pan-up | pan-down ] ] | manipulation
Initial:auto
Applies to:all elements except: non-replaced inline elements, table rows, row groups, table columns, and column groups.
Inherited:no
Percentages:N/A
Media:visual
Computed value:Same as specified value.

The touch-action CSS property determines whether direct manipulation interactions (which are not limited to touch, despite the property's name) MAY trigger the user agent's panning and zooming behavior. See the section on touch-action values.

Right before starting to pan or zoom, the user agent MUST suppress a pointer event stream if all of the following conditions are true:

Note
Some user agents implement complex gestures for behaviors that involve a series of separate discrete gestures, but which are all treated as part of a single continuous gesture. For example, consider a "fling to scroll" gesture on a touchscreen: a user starts panning the document with a rapid finger movement, lifts the finger from the touchscreen, and the document continues panning with simulated inertia. While the document is still moving, the user may place their finger on the touchscreen and execute another "fling" to provide further momentum for the panning, or counteract the current panning to slow it down, stop panning altogether, or reverse the direction of the panning. As this specification does not normatively define how gestures and behaviors are implemented, it is left up to the user agent to decide whether or not the second touch (before it is interpreted as a second "fling" or counteraction of the current panning) fires pointer events or not.
Note
touch-action does not apply/cascade through to embedded browsing contexts. For instance, even applying touch-action to an <iframe> won't have any effect on the behavior of direct manipulation interactions for panning and zooming within the <iframe> itself.

8.2 Determining supported direct manipulation behavior

When a user interacts with an element using a direct manipulation pointer (such as touch or stylus on a touchscreen), the effect of that input is determined by the value of the touch-action property, and the default direct manipulation behaviors of the element and its ancestors, as follows:

Note
Some user agents support panning and zooming interactions involving multiple concurrent pointers (e.g. multi-touch). Methods for processing or associating the touch-action values of multiple concurrent pointers is out of scope for this specification.

8.3 Details of touch-action values

The touch-action property covers direct manipulation behaviors related to viewport panning and zooming. Any additional user agent behaviors, such as text selection/highlighting, or activating links and form controls, MUST NOT be affected by this CSS property.

Note
The terms "panning" and "scrolling" are considered synonymous (or, more aptly, "panning" is "scrolling" using a direct manipulation input). Defining an interaction or gesture for triggering panning/scrolling, or for triggering behavior for the auto or none values, are out of scope for this specification.
auto
The user agent MAY consider any permitted direct manipulation behaviors related to panning and zooming of the viewport that begin on the element.
none
Direct manipulation interactions that begin on the element MUST NOT trigger behaviors related to viewport panning and zooming.
pan-x
pan-left
pan-right
pan-y
pan-up
pan-down
The user agent MAY consider direct manipulation interactions that begin on the element only for the purposes of panning that starts in any of the directions specified by all of the listed values. Once panning has started, the direction may be reversed by the user even if panning that starts in the reversed direction is disallowed. In contrast, when panning is restricted to a single axis (eg. pan-y), the axis cannot be changed during panning.

manipulation
The user agent MAY consider direct manipulation interactions that begin on the element only for the purposes of panning and continuous zooming (such as pinch-zoom), but MUST NOT trigger other related behaviors that rely on multiple activations that must happen within a set period of time (such as double-tap to zoom, or double-tap and hold for single-finger zoom).
Note
Additional touch-action values common in implementations are defined in [COMPAT].
Note
The touch-action property only applies to elements that support both the CSS width and height properties (see [CSS21]). This restriction is designed to facilitate user agent optimizations for low-latency direct manipulation panning and zooming. For elements not supported by default, such as <span> which is a non-replaced inline element, authors can set the display CSS property to a value, such as block, that supports width and height. Future specifications could extend this API to all elements.
Note

The direction-specific pan values are useful for customizing some overscroll behaviors. For example, to implement a simple pull-to-refresh effect the document's touch-action can be set to pan-x pan-down whenever the scroll position is 0 and pan-x pan-y otherwise. This allows pointer event handlers to define the behavior for upward panning/scrolling that start from the top of the document.

The direction-specific pan values can also be used for composing a component that implements custom panning with pointer event handling within an element that scrolls natively (or vice-versa). For example, an image carousel may use pan-y to ensure it receives pointer events for any horizontal pan operations without interfering with vertical panning of the document. When the carousel reaches its right-most extent, it may change its touch-action to pan-y pan-right so that a subsequent scroll operation beyond its extent can scroll the document within the viewport if possible. It's not possible to change the behavior of a panning/scrolling operation while it is taking place.

Note
Disabling some default direct manipulation behaviors for panning and zooming may allow user agents to respond to other behaviors more quickly. For example, with auto user agents typically add 300ms of delay before click to allow for double-tap gestures to be handled. In these cases, explicitly setting touch-action: none or touch-action: manipulation will remove this delay. Note that the methods for determining a tap or double-tap gesture are out of scope for this specification.
Example 5: Disallowing all direct manipulation behaviors
<div style="touch-action: none;">
    This element receives pointer events for all direct manipulation interactions that otherwise lead to panning or zooming.
</div>
Example 6: Allowing horizontal panning only
<div style="touch-action: pan-x;">
    This element receives pointer events when not panning in the horizontal direction.
</div>
Example 7: Child regions that disallow direct manipulation behaviors for panning and zooming
<div style="overflow: auto;">
    <div style="touch-action: none;">
        This element receives pointer events for all direct manipulation interactions that otherwise lead to panning or zooming.
    </div>
    <div>
        Direct manipulation interactions on this element MAY be consumed for manipulating the parent.
    </div>
</div>
Example 8: Intermediate parent that disallows direct manipulation behaviors for panning and zooming
<div style="overflow: auto;">
    <div style="touch-action: pan-y;">
        <div style="touch-action: pan-x;">
            This element receives pointer events for all direct manipulation interactions because
            it allows only horizontal panning yet an intermediate ancestor
            (between it and the scrollable element) only allows vertical panning.
            Therefore, no direct manipulation behaviors for panning/zooming are
            handled by the user agent.
        </div>
    </div>
</div>
Example 9: Intermediate parent that restricts allowed direct manipulation behaviors for panning and zooming
<div style="overflow: auto;">
    <div style="touch-action: pan-y pan-left;">
        <div style="touch-action: pan-x;">
            This element receives pointer events when not panning to the left.
        </div>
    </div>
</div>

9. Pointer capture

9.1 Introduction

This section is non-normative.

Pointer capture allows the events for a particular pointer (including any compatibility mouse events) to be retargeted to a particular element other than the normal hit test result of the pointer's location. This is useful in scenarios like a custom slider control (e.g. similar to the [HTML] <input type="range"> control). Pointer capture can be set on the slider thumb element, allowing the user to slide the control back and forth even if the pointer slides off of the thumb.

Custom Volume Slider
Figure 6 Example of a custom slider control that chooses a value by sliding the thumb element back and forth. After pointerdown on the thumb, pointer capture can be used to allow the user to slide the thumb even if the pointer drifts off of it.

9.2 Setting pointer capture

Pointer capture is set on an element of type Element by calling the element.setPointerCapture(pointerId) method. When this method is invoked, the user agent MUST run the following steps:

  1. If the pointerId provided as the method's argument does not match any of the active pointers, then throw a "NotFoundError" DOMException.
  2. Let the pointer be the active pointer specified by the given pointerId.
  3. If the element is not connected [DOM], throw an "InvalidStateError" DOMException.
  4. If this method is invoked while the element's node document [DOM] has a locked element ([PointerLock] pointerLockElement), throw an "InvalidStateError" DOMException.
  5. If the pointer is not in the active buttons state or the element's node document is not the active document of the pointer, then terminate these steps.
  6. For the specified pointerId, set the pending pointer capture target override to the Element on which this method was invoked.

9.3 Releasing pointer capture

Pointer capture is released on an element explicitly by calling the element.releasePointerCapture(pointerId) method. When this method is called, the user agent MUST run the following steps:

  1. If the pointerId provided as the method's argument does not match any of the active pointers and these steps are not being invoked as a result of the implicit release of pointer capture, then throw a "NotFoundError" DOMException.
  2. If hasPointerCapture is false for the Element with the specified pointerId, then terminate these steps.
  3. For the specified pointerId, clear the pending pointer capture target override, if set.

9.4 Implicit pointer capture

Inputs that implement direct manipulation interactions for panning and zooming (such as touch or stylus on a touchscreen) SHOULD behave exactly as if setPointerCapture() was called on the target element just before the invocation of any pointerdown listeners. The hasPointerCapture API may be used (eg. within any pointerdown listener) to determine whether this has occurred. If releasePointerCapture() is not called for the pointer before the next pointer event is fired, then a gotpointercapture event will be dispatched to the target (as normal) indicating that capture is active.

Note
This is a breaking change from [PointerEvents], but does not impact the vast majority of existing content. In addition to matching typical platform UX conventions, this design for implicit capture enables user agents to make a performance optimization which prevents the need to invoke hit-testing on touch movement events without explicit developer opt-in (consistent with the performance properties of existing dominant native and web APIs for touch input).
Note
In addition, user agents may implement implicit pointer capture behavior for all input devices on specific UI widgets such as input range controls (allowing some finger movement to stray outside of the form control itself during the interaction).

9.5 Implicit release of pointer capture

Immediately after firing the pointerup or pointercancel events, the user agent MUST clear the pending pointer capture target override for the pointerId of the pointerup or pointercancel event that was just dispatched, and then run process pending pointer capture steps to fire lostpointercapture if necessary. After running process pending pointer capture steps, if the pointer supports hover, user agent MUST also send corresponding boundary events necessary to reflect the current position of the pointer with no capture.

If the user agent supports firing the click event (see compatibility mouse events), and if in an implicit release scenario both click and lostpointercapture events are fired, click SHOULD be fired before lostpointercapture.

When the pointer capture target override is no longer connected [DOM], the pending pointer capture target override and pointer capture target override nodes SHOULD be cleared and also a PointerEvent named lostpointercapture corresponding to the captured pointer SHOULD be fired at the document.

When a pointer lock [PointerLock] is successfully applied on an element, the user agent MUST run the steps as if the releasePointerCapture() method has been called if any element is set to be captured or pending to be captured.

10. Coalesced and predicted events

Note
This specification does not define how user agents should coalesce or predict pointer movement data. It only specifies the API for accessing this information.

10.1 Coalesced events

For performance reasons, user agents may choose not to send a pointermove event every time a measurable property (such as coordinates, pressure, tangential pressure, tilt, twist, or contact geometry) of a pointer is updated. Instead, they may coalesce (combine/merge) multiple changes into a single pointermove or pointerrawupdate event. While this approach helps in reducing the amount of event handling the user agent must perform, it will naturally reduce the granularity and fidelity when tracking a pointer position, particularly for fast and large movements. Using the getCoalescedEvents() method it is possible for applications to access the raw, un-coalesced position changes. These allow for a more precise handling of pointer movement data. In the case of drawing applications, for instance, the un-coalesced events can be used to draw smoother curves that more closely match the actual movement of a pointer.

Close-up view of a curve, showing coalesced and un-coalesced points
Figure 7 Example of a curve in a drawing application — using only the coalesced coordinates from pointermove events (the grey dots), the curve is noticeably angular and jagged; the same line drawn using the more granular points provided by getCoalescedEvents() (the red circles) results in a smoother approximation of the pointer movement.

A PointerEvent has an associated coalesced events list (a list of zero or more PointerEvents). For trusted pointermove and pointerrawupdate events, the list is a sequence of all PointerEvents that were coalesced into this event. The "parent" trusted pointermove and pointerrawupdate event represents an accumulation of these coalesced events, but may have additional processing (for example to align with the display refresh rate). As a result, the coalesced events lists for these events always contain at least one event. For all other trusted event types, it is an empty list. Untrusted events have their coalesced events list initialized to the value passed to the constructor.

Note
Since a trusted parent event is a summary or aggregation of the coalesced events, developers should only need to process either the parent events or all of the coalesced events, but not both.

The events in the coalesced events list of a trusted event will have:

Example 10: Basic canvas drawing application using the coalesced events list
<style>
    /* Disable intrinsic user agent direct manipulation behaviors (such as panning or zooming)
    so that all events on the canvas element are given to the application instead. */

    canvas { touch-action: none; }
</style>

<canvas id="drawSurface" width="500px" height="500px" style="border:1px solid black;"></canvas>

<script>
    const canvas = document.getElementById("drawSurface"),
    context = canvas.getContext("2d");

    canvas.addEventListener("pointermove", (e)=> {

        if (e.getCoalescedEvents) {
            for (let coalesced_event of e.getCoalescedEvents()) {
                paint(coalesced_event); // Paint all raw/non-coalesced points
            }
        } else {
            paint(e); // Paint the final coalesced point
        }
    });

    function paint(event) {
        if(event.buttons>0) {
            context.fillRect(event.clientX, event.clientY, 5, 5);
        }
    }

</script>
Note
The PointerEvent's attributes will be initialized in a way that best represents the events in the coalesced events list. The specific method by which user agents should do this is not covered by this specification.

The order of all these dispatched events MUST match the actual order of the original events. For example if a pointerdown event causes the dispatch for the coalesced pointermove events the user agent MUST first dispatch one pointermove event with all those coalesced events of a pointerId followed by the pointerdown event.

Note

Here is an example of the actual events happening with increasing timeStamp values and the events dispatched by the user agent:

Actual eventsDispatched events
pointer (pointerId=2) coordinate changepointerrawupdate (pointerId=2) w/ one coalesced event
pointer (pointerId=1) coordinate changepointerrawupdate (pointerId=1) w/ one coalesced event
pointer (pointerId=2) coordinate changepointerrawupdate (pointerId=2) w/ one coalesced event
pointer (pointerId=2) coordinate changepointerrawupdate (pointerId=2) w/ one coalesced event
pointer (pointerId=1) coordinate changepointerrawupdate (pointerId=1) w/ one coalesced event
pointer (pointerId=2) coordinate changepointerrawupdate (pointerId=2) w/ one coalesced event
pointer (pointerId=1) button press pointermove (pointerId=1) w/ two coalesced events
pointermove (pointerId=2) w/ four coalesced events
pointerdown (pointerId=1) w/ zero coalesced events
pointer (pointerId=2) coordinate changepointerrawupdate (pointerId=2) w/ one coalesced event
pointer (pointerId=2) coordinate changepointerrawupdate (pointerId=2) w/ one coalesced event
pointer (pointerId=1) button release pointermove (pointerId=2) w/ two coalesced events
pointerup (pointerId=1) w/ zero coalesced events

10.2 Predicted events

Some user agents have built-in algorithms which, after a series of confirmed pointer movements, can make a prediction (based on past points, and the speed/trajectory of the movement) what the position of future pointer movements may be. Applications can use this information with the getPredictedEvents() method to speculatively "draw ahead" to a predicted position to reduce perceived latency, and then discarding these predicted points once the actual points are received.

A line drawn using coalesced points, showing predicted future points
Figure 8 Example of a line in a drawing application (the result of a drawing gesture from the bottom left to the top right), using the coalesced coordinates from pointermove events, showing the user agent's predicted future points (the grey circles).

A PointerEvent has an associated predicted events list (a list of zero or more PointerEvents). For trusted pointermove events, it is a sequence of PointerEvents that the user agent predicts will follow the event in the future. For all other trusted event types, it is an empty list. Untrusted events have their predicted events list initialized to the value passed to the constructor.

Note

While pointerrawmove events may have a non-empty coalesced events list, their predicted events list will, for performance reasons, usually be an empty list.

The number of events in the list and how far they are from the current timestamp are determined by the user agent and the prediction algorithm it uses.

The events in the predicted events list of a trusted event will have:

Note

Note that authors should only consider predicted events as valid predictions until the next pointer event is dispatched. It is possible, depending on how far into the future the user agent predicts events, that regular pointer events are dispatched earlier than the timestamp of one or more of the predicted events.

Example 11: Conceptual approach to drawing using coalesced events and predicted events

let predicted_points = [];
window.addEventListener("pointermove", function(event) {
    // Clear the previously drawn predicted points.
    for (let e of predicted_points.reverse()) {
        clearPoint(e.pageX, e.pageY);
    }

    // Draw the actual movements that happened since the last received event.
    for (let e of event.getCoalescedEvents()) {
        drawPoint(e.pageX, e.pageY);
    }

    // Draw the current predicted points to reduce the perception of latency.
    predicted_points = event.getPredictedEvents();
    for (let e of predicted_points) {
        drawPoint(e.pageX, e.pageY);
    }
});

10.3 Populating and maintaining the coalesced and predicted events lists

When a trusted PointerEvent is created, user agents SHOULD run the following steps for each event in the coalesced events list and predicted events list:

  1. Set the event's pointerId, pointerType, isPrimary and isTrusted to match the respective properties of the "parent" pointer event.
  2. Set the event's cancelable and bubbles to false (as these events will never be dispatched in isolation).
  3. Set the event's coalesced events list and predicted events list to an empty list.
  4. Initialize all other attributes to default PointerEvent values.

When a trusted PointerEvent's target is changed, user agents SHOULD, for each event in the coalesced events list and predicted events list:

  1. Set the event's target to match the target of the "parent" pointer event.

11. Compatibility mapping with mouse events

The vast majority of web content existing today codes only to Mouse Events. The following describes an algorithm for how the user agent MAY map generic pointer input to mouse events for compatibility with this content.

The compatibility mapping with mouse events is an OPTIONAL feature of this specification. User agents are encouraged to support the feature for best compatibility with existing legacy content. User agents that do not support compatibility mouse events are still encouraged to support the click and contextmenu events (see the note below).

The click and contextmenu events, defined in [UIEVENTS], are not considered compatibility mouse events as they are typically tied to user interface activation, and are fired from other (non-pointer) input devices, such as keyboards.

Note

In user agents that support firing click and/or contextmenu, calling preventDefault during a pointer event typically does not have an effect on whether click and/or contextmenu are fired or not. Because they are not compatibility mouse events, user agents typically fire click and contextmenu for all pointing devices, including pointers that are not primary pointers.

The relative ordering of these high-level events (click, contextmenu, focus, blur, etc.) with pointer events is undefined and varies between user agents. For example, in some user agents contextmenu will often follow a pointerup, in others it'll often precede a pointerup or pointercancel, and in some situations it may be fired without any corresponding pointer event (such as a keyboard shortcut).

In addition, user agents may apply their own heuristics to determine whether or not a click or contextmenu event should be fired. Some user agents may only fire these events for a primary pointer, and even then they may choose not to fire these events if there are other (non-primary) pointers of the same type, or other primary pointers of a different type. User agents may determine that a particular action was not a "clean" tap, click or long-press — for instance, if an interaction with a finger on a touch screen includes too much movement while the finger is in contact with the screen — and decide not to fire a click or contextmenu event. These aspects of user agent behavior are not defined in this specification, and they may differ between implementations.

Unless otherwise noted, the target of any mapped mouse event SHOULD be the same target as the respective pointer event unless the target is no longer participating in its ownerDocument's tree. In this case, the mouse event should be fired at the original target's nearest ancestor node (at the time it was removed from the tree) that still participates in its ownerDocument's tree, meaning that a new event path (based on the new target node) is built for the mouse event.

Authors can prevent the production of certain compatibility mouse events by canceling the pointerdown event.

Mouse events can only be prevented when the pointer is down. Hovering pointers (e.g. a mouse with no buttons pressed) cannot have their mouse events prevented.

The mouseover, mouseout, mouseenter, and mouseleave events are never prevented (even if the pointer is down).

Note

Compatibility mouse events can't be prevented when a pointer event EventListener is set to be passive [DOM].

11.1 Tracking the effective position of the legacy mouse pointer

While only the primary pointers can produce compatibility mouse events, multiple primary pointers can be active simultaneously, each producing its own compatibility mouse events. Since all these compatibility events would appear to MouseEvent code to be coming from a single mouse device, user agents are encouraged to guarantee that the compatibility mouse events are consistent from a single device perspective. For mouse transition events (i.e., mouseover, mouseout, mouseenter and mouseleave), this means the entry/exit state for every event target is valid as implied by [UIEVENTS]. Users agents SHOULD guarantee this by maintaining the effective position of the legacy mouse pointer in the document as follows.

Right before firing a pointerdown, pointerup or pointermove event, or a pointerleave event at the window, the user agent SHOULD run the following steps:

  1. Let T be the target of the pointerdown, pointerup or pointermove event being dispatched. For the pointerleave event, unset T.
  2. If T and current effective legacy mouse pointer position are both unset or they are equal, terminate these steps.
  3. Dispatch mouseover, mouseout, mouseenter and mouseleave events as per [UIEVENTS] for a mouse moving from the current effective legacy mouse pointer position to T. Consider an unset value of either current effective legacy mouse pointer position or T as an out-of-window mouse position.
  4. Set effective legacy mouse pointer position to T.

11.2 Mapping for devices that support hover

Whenever the user agent is to dispatch a pointer event for a device that supports hover, it SHOULD run the following steps:

  1. If the isPrimary property for the pointer event to be dispatched is false then dispatch the pointer event and terminate these steps.
  2. If the pointer event to be dispatched is a pointerdown, pointerup or pointermove event, or a pointerleave event at the window, dispatch compatibility mouse transition events as described in Tracking the effective position of the legacy mouse pointer.
  3. Dispatch the pointer event.
  4. If the pointer event dispatched was pointerdown and the event was canceled, then set the PREVENT MOUSE EVENT flag for this pointerType.
  5. If the PREVENT MOUSE EVENT flag is not set for this pointerType and the pointer event dispatched was:
  6. If the pointer event dispatched was pointerup or pointercancel, clear the PREVENT MOUSE EVENT flag for this pointerType.

11.3 Mapping for devices that do not support hover

Some devices, such as most touchscreens, do not support hovering a coordinate (or set of coordinates) while not in the active state. Much existing content coded to mouse events assumes that a mouse is producing the events and thus certain qualities are generally true:

Note
Hover is sometimes used to toggle the visibility of UI elements in content designed for mouse (e.g. "hover menus"). This content is often incompatible with devices that do not support hover. This specification does not define a mapping or behavior for compatibility with this scenario. It will be considered in a future version of the specification.

This requires that user agents provide a different mapping for these types of input devices. Whenever the user agent is to dispatch a pointer event for a device that does not support hover, it SHOULD run the following steps:

  1. If the isPrimary property for the pointer event to be dispatched is false then dispatch the pointer event and terminate these steps.
  2. If the pointer event to be dispatched is pointerover and the pointerdown event has not yet been dispatched for this pointer, then fire a mousemove event (for compatibility with legacy mouse-specific code).
  3. If the pointer event to be dispatched is a pointerdown, pointerup or pointermove event, or a pointerleave event at the window, dispatch compatibility mouse transition events as described in Tracking the effective position of the legacy mouse pointer.
  4. Dispatch the pointer event.
  5. If the pointer event dispatched was pointerdown and the event was canceled, then set the PREVENT MOUSE EVENT flag for this pointerType.
  6. If the PREVENT MOUSE EVENT flag is not set for this pointerType and the pointer event dispatched was:
  7. If the pointer event dispatched was pointerup or pointercancel, clear the PREVENT MOUSE EVENT flag for this pointerType.

If the user agent supports both Touch Events (as defined in [TOUCH-EVENTS]) and Pointer Events, the user agent MUST NOT generate both the compatibility mouse events as described in this section, and the fallback mouse events outlined in [TOUCH-EVENTS].

Note

The activation of an element (click) with a primary pointer that does not support hover (e.g. single finger on a touchscreen) would typically produce the following event sequence:

  1. mousemove
  2. pointerover
  3. pointerenter
  4. mouseover
  5. mouseenter
  6. pointerdown
  7. mousedown
  8. Zero or more pointermove and mousemove events, depending on movement of the pointer
  9. pointerup
  10. mouseup
  11. pointerout
  12. pointerleave
  13. mouseout
  14. mouseleave
  15. click

If, however, the pointerdown event is canceled during this interaction then the sequence of events would be:

  1. mousemove
  2. pointerover
  3. pointerenter
  4. mouseover
  5. mouseenter
  6. pointerdown
  7. Zero or more pointermove events, depending on movement of the pointer
  8. pointerup
  9. pointerout
  10. pointerleave
  11. mouseout
  12. mouseleave
  13. click

12. Converting between tiltX / tiltY and altitudeAngle / azimuthAngle

Pointer Events include two complementary sets of attributes to express the orientation of a transducer relative to the X-Y plane: tiltX / tiltY (introduced in the original Pointer Events specification), and azimuthAngle / altitudeAngle (adopted from the Touch Events - Level 2 specification).

Depending on the specific hardware and platform, user agents will likely only receive one set of values for the transducer orientation relative to the screen plane — either tiltX / tiltY or altitudeAngle / azimuthAngle. User agents MUST use the following algorithm for converting these values.

When the user agent calculates tiltX / tiltY from azimuthAngle / altitudeAngle it SHOULD round the final integer values using Math.round [ECMASCRIPT] rules.

Example 12: Converting between tiltX/tiltY and altitudeAngle/azimuthAngle
/* Converting between tiltX/tiltY and altitudeAngle/azimuthAngle */

function spherical2tilt(altitudeAngle, azimuthAngle){
  const radToDeg = 180/Math.PI;

  let tiltXrad = 0;
  let tiltYrad = 0;

  if(altitudeAngle == 0){
    // the pen is in the X-Y plane
    if(azimuthAngle == 0 || azimuthAngle == 2*Math.PI){
      // pen is on positive X axis
      tiltXrad = Math.PI/2;
    }
    if(azimuthAngle == Math.PI/2){
      // pen is on positive Y axis
      tiltYrad = Math.PI/2;
    }
    if(azimuthAngle == Math.PI){
      // pen is on negative X axis
      tiltXrad = -Math.PI/2;
    }
    if(azimuthAngle == 3*Math.PI/2){
      // pen is on negative Y axis
      tiltYrad = -Math.PI/2;
    }
    if(azimuthAngle>0 && azimuthAngle<Math.PI/2){
      tiltXrad = Math.PI/2;
      tiltYrad = Math.PI/2;
    }
    if(azimuthAngle>Math.PI/2 && azimuthAngle<Math.PI){
      tiltXrad = -Math.PI/2;
      tiltYrad = Math.PI/2;
    }
    if(azimuthAngle>Math.PI && azimuthAngle<3*Math.PI/2){
      tiltXrad = -Math.PI/2;
      tiltYrad = -Math.PI/2;
    }
    if(azimuthAngle>3*Math.PI/2 && azimuthAngle<2*Math.PI){
      tiltXrad = Math.PI/2;
      tiltYrad = -Math.PI/2;
    }
  }

  if(altitudeAngle != 0){
    const tanAlt = Math.tan(altitudeAngle);

    tiltXrad = Math.atan(Math.cos(azimuthAngle) / tanAlt);
    tiltYrad = Math.atan(Math.sin(azimuthAngle) / tanAlt);
  }

  return {"tiltX":tiltXrad*radToDeg, "tiltY":tiltYrad*radToDeg};
}

function tilt2spherical(tiltX, tiltY){
  const tiltXrad = tiltX * Math.PI/180;
  const tiltYrad = tiltY * Math.PI/180;

  // calculate azimuth angle
  let azimuthAngle = 0;

  if(tiltX == 0){
    if(tiltY > 0){
      azimuthAngle = Math.PI/2;
    }
    else if(tiltY < 0){
      azimuthAngle = 3*Math.PI/2;
    }
  } else if(tiltY == 0){
    if(tiltX < 0){
      azimuthAngle = Math.PI;
    }
  } else if(Math.abs(tiltX) == 90 || Math.abs(tiltY) == 90){
    // not enough information to calculate azimuth
    azimuthAngle = 0;
  } else {
    // Non-boundary case: neither tiltX nor tiltY is equal to 0 or +-90
    const tanX = Math.tan(tiltXrad);
    const tanY = Math.tan(tiltYrad);

    azimuthAngle = Math.atan2(tanY, tanX);
    if(azimuthAngle < 0){
      azimuthAngle += 2*Math.PI;
    }
  }

  // calculate altitude angle
  let altitudeAngle = 0;

  if (Math.abs(tiltX) == 90 || Math.abs(tiltY) == 90){
      altitudeAngle = 0
  } else if (tiltX == 0){
    altitudeAngle = Math.PI/2 - Math.abs(tiltYrad);
  } else if(tiltY == 0){
    altitudeAngle = Math.PI/2 - Math.abs(tiltXrad);
  } else {
    // Non-boundary case: neither tiltX nor tiltY is equal to 0 or +-90
    altitudeAngle =  Math.atan(1.0/Math.sqrt(Math.pow(Math.tan(tiltXrad),2) + Math.pow(Math.tan(tiltYrad),2)));
  }

  return {"altitudeAngle":altitudeAngle, "azimuthAngle":azimuthAngle};
}

13. Security and privacy considerations

This appendix discusses security and privacy considerations for Pointer Events implementations. The discussion is limited to security and privacy issues that arise directly from implementation of the event model, APIs and events defined in this specification.

Many of the event types defined in this specification are dispatched in response to user actions. This allows malicious event listeners to gain access to information users would typically consider confidential, e.g., the exact path/movement of a user's mouse/stylus/finger while interacting with a page.

Pointer events contain additional information (where supported by the user's device), such as the angle or tilt at which a pen input is held, the geometry of the contact surface, and the pressure exerted on the stylus or touch screen. Information about angle, tilt, geometry and pressure are directly related to sensors on the user's device, meaning that this specification allows an origin access to these sensors.

This sensor data, as well as the ability to determine the type of input mechanism (mouse, touch, pen) used, may be used to infer characteristics of a user, or of the user's device and environment. These inferred characteristics and any device/environment information may themselves be sensitive — for instance, they may allow a malicious site to further infer if a user is using assistive technologies. This information can also be potentially used for the purposes of building a user profile and/or attempting to "fingerprint" and track a particular user.

As mitigation, user agents may consider including the ability for users to disable access to particular sensor data (such as angle, tilt, pressure), and/or to make it available only after an explicit opt-in from the user.

Beyond these considerations, the working group believes that this specification:

14. Glossary

This section is non-normative.

active buttons state
The condition when a pointer has a non-zero value for the buttons property. For mouse, this is when the device has at least one button depressed. For touch, this is when there is physical contact with the digitizer. For pen, this is when either the pen has physical contact with the digitizer, or at least one button is depressed while hovering.
active document
For every active pointer, the document that received the last event from that pointer.
active pointer
Any touch contact, pen/stylus, mouse cursor, or other pointer that can produce events. If it is possible for a given pointer (identified by a unique pointerId) to produce additional events within the document, then that pointer is still considered active. Examples:
  • A mouse connected to the device is always active.
  • A touch contact on the screen is considered active.
  • If a touch contact or pen/stylus is lifted beyond the range of the digitizer, then it is no longer considered active.
Note
On some platforms, the set of active pointers includes all pointer input to the device, including any that are not targeted at the user agent (e.g. those targeted at other applications).
canceled event
An event whose default action was prevented by means of preventDefault(), returning false in an event handler, or other means as defined by [UIEVENTS] and [HTML].
contact geometry
The bounding box of an input (most commonly, touch) on a digitizer. This typically refers to devices with coarser pointer input resolution than a single pixel. Some devices do not report this data at all.
digitizer
A type of input sensing device in which a surface can detect input which is in contact and/or in close proximity. Most commonly, this is the surface that senses input from the touch contact or a pen/stylus.
direct manipulation
Certain user agents (such as browsers on a touchscreen device) implement a "direct manipulation" metaphor where a pointer not only interacts with controls, but is also used to directly pan or zoom the current page, providing the illusion of direct physical contact. As an example, users on a touchscreen device are generally able to use a finger or a stylus to "grab" a page and pan it by moving the pointer, directly manipulating the page. Contrast this with a mouse pointer on a regular desktop/laptop, where panning is done by using a scrollbar, rather than by "dragging" the page.
Note
In some cases, touchpads (like those found on a laptop) will allow the user to scroll by "dragging" on the touchpad. However, this is generally achieved by the touchpad generating "fake" mouse wheel events, so this wouldn't count as a direct manipulation.
hit test
The process by which the user agent determines a target element for a pointer event. Typically, this is determined by considering the pointer's location and also the visual layout of elements in a document on screen media.
measurable properties

Measurable properties represent values relating to continuous pointer sensor data that is expressed using a real number or an integer from a large domain. For pointer events, width, height, pressure, tangentialPressure, tiltX, tiltY, twist, altitudeAngle, azimuthAngle, and the [UIEVENTS] Mouse Event model properties screenX, screenY, clientX, clientY are measurable properties.

In contrast pointerId, pointerType, isPrimary, and the [UIEVENTS] Mouse Event model properties button, buttons, ctrlKey, shiftKey, altKey, and metaKey are not considered measurable properties, as they don't relate to sensor data.

pointer
A hardware agnostic representation of input devices that can target a specific coordinate (or set of coordinates) on a screen, such as a mouse, pen, or touch contact.
user agent
A program, such as a browser or content authoring tool, normally running on a client machine, which acts on a user's behalf in retrieving, interpreting, executing, presenting, or creating content.

A. Acknowledgments

Many thanks to lots of people for their proposals and recommendations, some of which are incorporated into this document. The group's Chair acknowledges contributions from the following past and present group members and participants: Mustaq Ahmed, Arthur Barstow, Ben Boyle, Matt Brubeck, Rick Byers, Marcos Cáceres, Cathy Chan, Bo Cupp, Domenic Denicola, Ted Dinklocker, Robert Flack, Dave Fleck, Mike Fraser, Ella Ge, Scott González, Kartikaya Gupta, Philippe Le Hégaret, Hayato Ito, Patrick Kettner, Patrick H. Lauke, Scott Low, Sangwhan Moon, Olli Pettay, Alan Pyne, Antoine Quint, Jacob Rossi, Kagami Sascha Rosylight, Doug Schepers, Ming-Chou Shih, Brenton Simpson, Dave Tapuska, Liviu Tinta, Asir Vedamuthu, Lan Wei, Navid Zolghadr

Special thanks to those that helped pioneer the first edition of this model, including especially: Charu Chandiram, Peter Freiling, Nathan Furtwangler, Thomas Olsen, Matt Rakow, Ramu Ramanathan, Justin Rogers, Jacob Rossi, Reed Townsend and Steve Wright.

B. Revision history

This section is non-normative.

The following is an informative summary of substantial and major editorial changes between publications of this specification, relative to the [PointerEvents2] specification. See the complete revision history of the Editor's Drafts of this specification.

C. References

C.1 Normative references

[CSS-OVERFLOW-3]
CSS Overflow Module Level 3. David Baron; Elika Etemad; Florian Rivoal. W3C. 23 December 2021. W3C Working Draft. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/css-overflow-3/
[CSS21]
Cascading Style Sheets Level 2 Revision 1 (CSS 2.1) Specification. Bert Bos; Tantek Çelik; Ian Hickson; Håkon Wium Lie. W3C. 7 June 2011. W3C Recommendation. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/CSS21/
[CSSOM-VIEW]
CSSOM View Module. Simon Pieters. W3C. 17 March 2016. W3C Working Draft. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/cssom-view-1/
[DOM]
DOM Standard. Anne van Kesteren. WHATWG. Living Standard. URL: https://dom.spec.whatwg.org/
[ECMASCRIPT]
ECMAScript Language Specification. Ecma International. URL: https://tc39.es/ecma262/multipage/
[HTML]
HTML Standard. Anne van Kesteren; Domenic Denicola; Ian Hickson; Philip Jägenstedt; Simon Pieters. WHATWG. Living Standard. URL: https://html.spec.whatwg.org/multipage/
[PointerLock]
Pointer Lock. Vincent Scheib. W3C. 27 October 2016. W3C Recommendation. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/pointerlock/
[RFC2119]
Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate Requirement Levels. S. Bradner. IETF. March 1997. Best Current Practice. URL: https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc2119
[RFC8174]
Ambiguity of Uppercase vs Lowercase in RFC 2119 Key Words. B. Leiba. IETF. May 2017. Best Current Practice. URL: https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8174
[TOUCH-EVENTS]
Touch Events. Doug Schepers; Sangwhan Moon; Matt Brubeck; Arthur Barstow. W3C. 10 October 2013. W3C Recommendation. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/touch-events/
[UIEVENTS]
UI Events. Gary Kacmarcik; Travis Leithead. W3C. 1 June 2022. W3C Working Draft. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/uievents/
[WEBIDL]
Web IDL Standard. Edgar Chen; Timothy Gu. WHATWG. Living Standard. URL: https://webidl.spec.whatwg.org/

C.2 Informative references

[COMPAT]
Compatibility Standard. Mike Taylor. WHATWG. Living Standard. URL: https://compat.spec.whatwg.org/
[PointerEvents]
Pointer Events. Jacob Rossi; Matt Brubeck. W3C. 4 April 2019. W3C Recommendation. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/pointerevents/
[PointerEvents2]
Pointer Events. Matt Brubeck; Rick Byers; Patrick Lauke; Navid Zolghadr. W3C. 4 April 2019. W3C Recommendation. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/pointerevents2/
[WCAG21]
Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1. Andrew Kirkpatrick; Joshue O'Connor; Alastair Campbell; Michael Cooper. W3C. 5 June 2018. W3C Recommendation. URL: https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG21/