Encoding specification Disposition of Comments for CR

Id	Summary [issue title]	From	Status [O/C] open closed	Decision [A/R/Q] accepted rejected question	Responder [S/U] satisfied unsatisfied	Changes [PR title(s) with link]	Type [E/S/I] editorial substantive indexchange	Tests [!/c] change! changed
76	Editorial style nits	domenic	o				e
75	Confusion between Big5 and Big5-HKSCS encodings	bhaible	o				?
74	Confusion between KOI8-U and KOI8-RU encodings	bhaible	o				?
73	windows-1255 encoding: add mapping for 0xCA	bhaible	c	a		windows-1255 map 0xCA to U+05BA	i	!
72	Add Streams support	annevk	o				?
10	Clarify scope of document in preface	nigelmegitt	c	a	s	point out utf-8/utf-16be/utf-16le encoder equivalence with the Unicode standard	e	-
11	The title of the document needs to be more than one (commonly used) word	dswinger	c	r	u	none	e	-
12	Signaling EOF in the streaming case is unspecified (or too unclear)	hsivonen	c	a		clarify how decode() handles end-of-stream	?	-
13	Streaming should be a flag on the decoder instead of being a flag on the decode() call	hsivonen	c	a		clarify how decode() handles end-of-stream	?	-
14	Add do not flush flag to encode API, accept DOMString	inexorabletash	c	r		none	-	-
15	iso-2022-jp encoder XSS risks	t-tera	c	a	s	Fix #15: prevent ISO-2022-JP encoder attack #34	s	c
16	UTf7 supports	lygstate	c	r		none	-	-
17	"gb18030 ranges" have problematic definitions	peteroupc	c	a		Fix #17: gb18030 cannot encode U+E5E5	s	c
18	Consider removing TextEncoder support for UTF-16	hsivonen	c	a		Fix #18: remove UTF-16 support from TextEncoder	s	api
19	Unclear text in utf-8 decoder	r12a	c	a	s	reword utf-8 decoder step to avoid extra parenthesis	e	-
20	Clarify result of division in algorithms	r12a	c	a	s	rather than relying on integer division, use floor()	e	-
21	Treatment of U+2022 is incorrect in Shift_JIS, EUC-JP and ISO-2022-JP	jungshik	c	a		Japanese encoders have special treatment for U+2212, not U+2022	s	c
22	GB 18030 2000 vs 2005	jungshik	c	a		align with GB18030-2005	s	c
24	BufferSource is not specified	phistuck	c	r	s	none	-	-
27	Remove the last 14 characters PUA of GB18030-2005	lygstate	o	r	Reopened	none	?	-
28	What's the correct choice for BIG5 F9FE?	lygstate	c	q		none	-	-
29	Introduce "output encoding"	annevk	c	a	s	introduce output encoding for URL and HTML forms	s	!
31	SHIFT_JISX0213 are not supported	lygstate	c	r		none	-	-
32	Consider making the DOM name the canonical name	hsivonen	c	a		use the encoding name exposed by DOM and HTML <form>	Editorial	no change
33	Replacement encoding should handle empty input better	annevk	c	a	s	handle empty input better for the replacement decoder	e	!
40	Adding BRF as "legacy" single-byte encoding for braille	sthibaul	c	r		none	-	-
42	utf-8 decoder lead byte switch branches 0xE0 to 0xEF, 0xF0 to 0xF4 need 'return continue'	inexorabletash	c	a	s	Fix regression in utf-8 decoder #45	e	-
47	index-jis0208.txt should be JIS X 0208 and add another index file	takahashim	o				e
49	Group constants together in half-width math	hsivonen	c	a	s	Editorial: avoid upsetting lazy compilers	e	unchanged
50	Editorial: Add a note about duplicates to "index Shift_JIS pointer" #50	hsivonen	c	a		Editorial: point out that Shift_JIS contains duplicate code points	e	-
51	Editorial: Exclude index entries instead of just pointers #51	hsivonen	c	a		Editorial: make it clearer what index pointer exclusion means	e	-
52	Editorial optimization: Move EUDC before index lookup #52	hsivonen	c	a		Handle EUDC before the index in Shift_JIS	e	c
53	Please double-check the end of the EUDC range #53	hsivonen	c	a		Correct Shift_JIS EUDC range	s	c
63	Editorial: Clean up gb18030 math	hsivonen	c	a		Editorial: make gb18030 math more clear	e
64	Correct [Exposed] syntax	ms2ger	c	a		Correct IDL Exposed syntax	e
66	In equations, all numbers are integers, additio...	ricea	o	a			e
67	URL parsing HTML form submission	ricea	c	a		Editorial: add "and" to note	e
68	Add UTF-7 to replacement encoding list?	jungshik	o				?
69	TextEncoder#encode - write to existing Uint8Array	maciejhirsz	o				?
70	Consider adding "replacement" as a label for the replacement encoding	hsivonen	o				?

Id	Summary	From	Status	Decision	Responder	Changes	Type	Tests
76	Editorial style nits	domenic	Open				Editorial
75	Confusion between Big5 and Big5-HKSCS encodings	bhaible	Open				?
74	Confusion between KOI8-U and KOI8-RU encodings	bhaible	Open				?
73	windows-1255 encoding: add mapping for 0xCA	bhaible	Closed	Accepted		windows-1255 map 0xCA to U+05BA	Index changed	Change!
72	Add Streams support	annevk	Open				?
70	Consider adding "replacement" as a label for the replacement encoding	hsivonen	Open				?
69	TextEncoder#encode - write to existing Uint8Array	maciejhirsz	Open				?
68	Add UTF-7 to replacement encoding list?	jungshik	Open				?
67	URL parsing HTML form submission	ricea	Closed	Accepted		Editorial: add "and" to note	Editorial
66	In equations, all numbers are integers, additio...	ricea	Open	Accepted			Editorial
64	Correct [Exposed] syntax	ms2ger	Closed	Accepted		Correct IDL Exposed syntax	Editorial
63	Editorial: Clean up gb18030 math	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		Editorial: make gb18030 math more clear	Editorial
53	Please double-check the end of the EUDC range #53	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		Correct Shift_JIS EUDC range	Substantive	Done
52	Editorial optimization: Move EUDC before index lookup #52	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		Handle EUDC before the index in Shift_JIS	Editorial	Done
51	Editorial: Exclude index entries instead of just pointers #51	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		Editorial: make it clearer what index pointer exclusion means	Editorial	-
50	Editorial: Add a note about duplicates to "index Shift_JIS pointer" #50	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		Editorial: point out that Shift_JIS contains duplicate code points	Editorial	-
49	Group constants together in half-width math	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted	Satisfied	Editorial: avoid upsetting lazy compilers	Editorial	unchanged
47	index-jis0208.txt should be JIS X 0208 and add another index file	takahashim	Open				Editorial
42	utf-8 decoder lead byte switch branches 0xE0 to 0xEF, 0xF0 to 0xF4 need 'return continue'	inexorabletash	Closed	Accepted	Satisfied	Fix regression in utf-8 decoder #45	Editorial	-
40	Adding BRF as "legacy" single-byte encoding for braille	sthibaul	Closed	Rejected		none	-	-
33	Replacement encoding should handle empty input better	annevk	Closed	Accepted	Satisfied	handle empty input better for the replacement decoder	Editorial	Change!
32	Consider making the DOM name the canonical name	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		use the encoding name exposed by DOM and HTML <form>	Editorial	no change
31	SHIFT_JISX0213 are not supported	lygstate	Closed	Rejected		none	-	-
29	Introduce "output encoding"	annevk	Closed	Accepted	Satisfied	introduce output encoding for URL and HTML forms	Substantive	Change!
28	What's the correct choice for BIG5 F9FE?	lygstate	Closed	Question		none	-	-
27	Remove the last 14 characters PUA of GB18030-2005	lygstate	Open	Rejected	Reopened	none	?	-
24	BufferSource is not specified	phistuck	Closed	Rejected	Satisfied	none	-	-
22	GB 18030 2000 vs 2005	jungshik	Closed	Accepted		align with GB18030-2005	Substantive	Done
21	Treatment of U+2022 is incorrect in Shift_JIS, EUC-JP and ISO-2022-JP	jungshik	Closed	Accepted		Japanese encoders have special treatment for U+2212, not U+2022	Substantive	Done
20	Clarify result of division in algorithms	r12a	Closed	Accepted	Satisfied	rather than relying on integer division, use floor()	Editorial	-
19	Unclear text in utf-8 decoder	r12a	Closed	Accepted	Satisfied	reword utf-8 decoder step to avoid extra parenthesis	Editorial	-
18	Consider removing TextEncoder support for UTF-16	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		Fix #18: remove UTF-16 support from TextEncoder	Substantive	api
17	"gb18030 ranges" have problematic definitions	peteroupc	Closed	Accepted		Fix #17: gb18030 cannot encode U+E5E5	Substantive	Done
16	UTf7 supports	lygstate	Closed	Rejected		none	-	-
15	iso-2022-jp encoder XSS risks	t-tera	Closed	Accepted	Satisfied	Fix #15: prevent ISO-2022-JP encoder attack #34	Substantive	Done
14	Add do not flush flag to encode API, accept DOMString	inexorabletash	Closed	Rejected		none	-	-
13	Streaming should be a flag on the decoder instead of being a flag on the decode() call	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		clarify how decode() handles end-of-stream	?	-
12	Signaling EOF in the streaming case is unspecified (or too unclear)	hsivonen	Closed	Accepted		clarify how decode() handles end-of-stream	?	-
11	The title of the document needs to be more than one (commonly used) word	dswinger	Closed	Rejected	Not satisfied	none	Editorial	-
10	Clarify scope of document in preface	nigelmegitt	Closed	Accepted	Satisfied	point out utf-8/utf-16be/utf-16le encoder equivalence with the Unicode standard	Editorial	-

Encoding specification Disposition of Comments for CR period, October 2016