W3C

– DRAFT –
ixml community group call

16 April 2024

Attendees

Present
Michael, Norm, Steven
Regrets
Bethan, John
Chair
Steven
Scribe
Norm

Meeting minutes

Review of previous actions

2023-01-10-f continues

2023-11-28-c completed

ACTION: 2024-04-16-a MSM to incorporate Steven's comments into the EBNF document

2024-03-05-c in progress, continues

2024-03-19-a: continues

Steven: W3C says that they'd rather not delete the link

ACTION: 2024-04-16-b Norm to reconstruct the previous W3C-styled draft

Steven: They also report a 404 in the report itself, the "latest published version" link is broken

ACTION: 2024-04-16-c Norm to sort out the broken link

Status of implementations

No reports this time.

Status of tests and test suites

Michael: At some point in the minutes, we recorded "oh well, if we're adopting the normalization of line breaks on input, we need some test cases."

ACTION: 2024-04-16-d: Michael to open an issue about adding line break normalization tests

Review and resolution of bug reports and technical issues

Steven: #245, invisibleXML/ixml#245

Michael: I've looked at it shallowly.

Norm: Me too.

Michael: The spot checks I did all looked fine. The CRs in the output should go away.

Norm: I think if we're going to add line break tests, I'm happy to accept these changes.

Michael: I'm tempted to say we should merge it.

Norm: I think that's fine.

ACTION: 2024-04-16-e: Norm to merge #245

Steven: I'm inclined to say that we shouldn't resolve normative issues when there are only three of us.

Version numbers (discussion)

<Steven> https://www.w3.org/2024/04/02-ixml-minutes.html

<Steven> https://www.w3.org/2024/04/02-ixml-minutes.html#t12

Michael: What's the status of #243?

Some discussion ensues. Norm believes he revised the PR to reflect the comments from the last meeting.

https://invisiblexml.org/pr/243/autodiff.html

General agreement that the PR now reflects what the author was asked to do.

Steven expresses reservations about the ixml:state attribute

Adjourned

Summary of action items

  1. 2024-04-16-a MSM to incorporate Steven's comments into the EBNF document
  2. 2024-04-16-b Norm to reconstruct the previous W3C-styled draft
  3. 2024-04-16-c Norm to sort out the broken link
  4. 2024-04-16-d: Michael to open an issue about adding line break normalization tests
  5. 2024-04-16-e: Norm to merge #245
Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 221 (Fri Jul 21 14:01:30 2023 UTC).

Diagnostics

Succeeded: s/You're on the hook, but I was here early so I thought I'd do something in the meantime//

Succeeded: s/04-16a/04-16-a/

Maybe present: 2024-03-19-a

All speakers: 2024-03-19-a, Michael, Norm, Steven

Active on IRC: norm, Steven