Meeting minutes
Minutes
TPAC
Ege: any changes about the attendance?
Cris: not sure yet
… so pleas add me to "not Clear"
Luca: same here
Ege: (adds Cristiano and Luca to "not Clear")
… what about you Koster?
Koster: remote
Ege: topics for TD?
… at least JSON-LD collab
Luca: might want to talk about data mapping in general
… how to use data schema, etc.
Koster: RDF applications and design pattern in general
… sort of related to data mapping
… could be handled by RDF or maybe by JSON
… what is the pattern for that purpose?
Ege: think what Luca means is rather payload level
Kaz: "data mapping in general" is a bit vague
… could you elaborate it a bit more?
… what king of data withing TD or Binding Template to be mapped to what?
Luca: supporting JSON-LD without full JSON-LD processing
… also how to use data schema
… in my use case of labeling some device
… how to use the data schema in a clearer manner
Kaz: ok
… would be helpful if you could describe that based on a concrete use case scenario
… when we discuss the topic (not now :)
Luca: ok, will prepare something for that purpose
Ege: Koster, do you want to talk about TD in RDF?
Koster: semantic annotation to have richer information
… all the information to be integrated
… maybe need to elaborate the idea a bit more
Cris: basically would support those points
… also validaton of different ontology models
… how to work with Things
… btw, are we starting with brainstorming there during TPAC?
Ege: yeah
Cris: how long?
Ege: would have topics first
Cris: maybe less than two hours?
Ege: need to check
Kaz: please think about concrete use cases
… and if possibly try some broader example like smart cities, smart building, etc.
… also please remember McCool mentioned we could have a preleminary or followup meeting before or after TPAC
Mizushima: we should build consensus about what to be described by TD spec
Kaz: you mean refactoring of the spec?
Mizushima: yes
… the expected spec will be Ver. 2.0
… so it's a major version up
… therefore we should make consensus about what to do there
Ege: right
… explaining the major version udpate
… including major refactoring
Sebastian: be aware TPAC will be held in September
… on the other hand, many of the topics here are relevant for the upcoming months too
Ege: yeah
… we don't need to wait
Kaz: as McCool mentioned during the main call, we're planning to have a dedicated meeting in June
… to think about what to do in the next Charter period
… so we can talk about some of these topics there
Ege: you can add further update to the wiki
Ege: please put your name when you add edits
Binding Templates
PR 290
wot-binding-templates PR 290 - Publication Prep
Ege: Kaz let us know about the basic procedure for publication
<Ege> https://
Ege: put the information to README.md under wot-binding-templates
… checking the document using the Pubrules checker
… wondering how to change the document status
Kaz: you can specify the document type using the ReSpec parameter
… you can look at the ReSpec page to see the detail
Ege: ok
Ege: seems HTML Tidy doesn't work properly
Kaz: please try "tidy -i -m Overview.html"
… note that if there is some fatal/difficult error, Tidy gives up to fix the HTML
… there is a Tidy documentation, also you can simply use "tidy --help"
Kaz: I myself usually use a Makefile for that purpose, and can share that file with you
Ege: tx
Kaz: once you've confirmed the HTML is OK with the Pubrules checker, Validator, Link Checker, etc., I can double check it and work on the publication
Ege: how to get the information on the Validator and the Link Checker?
Kaz: there are links from the Pubrules checker results
… please see also the /Guide page above
Ege: ok
… will work on the checker again
TD
issue #1831
<kaz> wot-thing-description Issue 1831 - Problem with Respec
Ege: close
Ege: PRs
PR #1826
<kaz> wot-thing-description PR 1826 - Resolve privacy-immutable-id-as-property
… didn't get implementations, removed assertion and changed language to should (lower case)
Ege: any objections to merge?
… merged
PR #1827
<kaz> wot-thing-description PR 1827 - Resolve security-context-secure-fetch
Ege: try https first for remote links
… also removed assertion and changed language to should
… any objections to merging?
… merged
PR #1828
<kaz> wot-thing-description PR 1828 - Resolve td-security-oauth2-device-flow
Ege: remove device flow from Oauth
… only client and code flows are left
… also removed a reference to the device flow in the discovery spec
Ege: any objections to merge?
Ege: merged
Ege: changed editors notes (PR #1811)
PR #1811
<kaz> wot-thing-description PR 1811 - Resolve 3 editors notes
Ege: changed editors notes to notes
Jan: is this paragraph still a note in the document?
<McCool_> Instead of a periodic POST call to the Thing
Ege: (edited the PR online)
… any objections ?
… merged
… these are all the editorial PRs
PR #1830
<kaz> wot-thing-description PR 1830 - WIP: Final Implementation Report update
Implementation Report update
Ege: should remove the "at-risk" list
Ege: (display the rendered file)
… all at-risk items should be gone
Ege: any objections to merge?
… merged
Ege: done with the agenda
Issue #1807 TM namespace not active yet
<kaz> wot-thing-description Issue 1807 - TM namespace not active yet
… the reference needs to change from 2019 to 2022 vesion
Ege: it could fail validation
Kaz: we need the specific from and to URLs
… for the mapping
… it would be easier to create a subdirectory under the main directory
Ege: don't see a tm context
Kaz: otherwise a level of approval is needed for each revision
Ege: we are done, any other business?
<kaz> Namespace allocation guide
Ege: thank you, adjourned