Meeting minutes
Minutes
approved
Updated results
McCool: would like to finalize the features at-risk
PR 571
PR 571 - Update Siemens/Logilab test results
McCool: should go ahead and merge it
… any objections?
(none)
merged
PR 572
PR 572 - Update Intel wot-ha results
McCool: (goes through the changes)
McCool: started to work on multi language stuff
… looked OK to me, but the test is broken
… so kind of reluctant to merge this
… but could merge this and add fixes later
… any problems to overwrite the failed assertions?
McCool: failed due to some inconsistency...
… but can not see any problems with the data itself
McCool: any opinion about translating the title of "WoT Thing Description" into Japanese?
Kaz: the translation work for TD by the WoT-JP CG is still ongoing, but I thought they were simply using "WoT Thing Description" in English as the title for the JP version as well
McCool: would it be OK to merge this PR itself?
Kaz: would be better to ask Ege for clarification about this kind of errors and warnings
McCool: yeah, I know
Kaz: if the data can be processed for the implementation report correctly, I'm OK with merging this PR itself
… but checking with Ege as the developer of the validator would be helpful
McCool: yeah, maybe the check is too strict
PR itself has been merged
Updated implementation report for Discovery
McCool: (regenerates the updated implementation report)
McCool: got an updated result, and would like to update the features at-risk results on the README.md as well
Kaz: what about the remaining two PRs on the wot-testing repo?
PR 570 - Update node-wot manual csv
PR 569 - Update manual.csv for dart_wot
McCool: those are for TD
… would like to see the Discovery results first
Kaz: ok
McCool: (updates the Testfest README.md again)
… still some stuff left over there
… pagination things and language things can be handled by me, since only one more implementation is needed
McCool: one problem is around tdd-http-alternate-language
Kaz: given we've not got any implementations so far, maybe there is no strong need for this feature. However, maybe should see the need from the industry again.
McCool: maybe need to give up to implement this myself
… would be better to work on pagination
… also there is a note saying "the process of modifying the default language of a TD using translations already provided in a TD is described in the WoT Thing Description 1.1 specification."
… by Wednesday, May 17, we should handle "introduction-dns-sd-service-name-udp" as well
… pretty sure can handle all the high priority features
High Priority List of higher-priority assertions with at least one implementation: (1) tdd-registrationinfo-expiry-config - Intel (1) tdd-things-list-pagination-order-utf-8 These are in support of internationalization, and were added based on wide review, so should be a relatively high priority. (2) tdd-http-alternate-language - Intel (1) tdd-validation-response-lang - Intel Following are for ordering results. Some of these are implied by tdd-things-list-pagination-order-utf-8 which is satisfied: (1) tdd-things-list-pagination-order - Logilab (1) tdd-things-list-pagination-orderable - Logilab (1) tdd-things-list-pagination-order-nextlink - Logilab
Kaz: could you git commit the latest updated implementation report to GitHub?
McCool: ok
… (creates a PR for that purpose)
<McCool> wot-discovery PR 478 - 15 May 2023 implementation report update
McCool: would like to merge the above PR
Kaz: ok
McCool: (fixes minor conflicts before merging)
merged
updated implementation report for Discovery
McCool: will fix the stuff other than the results too
… there are failures but we have enough passes for them
… (skims the updated implementation report)
… lacking implementations for "21: introduction-dns-sd-service-name-udp" and "22: introduction-dns-sd-service-name-directory-udp", etc.
… will work on them
… and we'll summarize the situation on Wednesday
Kaz: yeah, given the situation, the question is simply "when to wrap up"
McCool: yeah
… there are two more days for that purpose
[adjourned]