Meeting minutes
Minutes
Lagally: (goes through the minutes)
approved
Wide reviews
<mlagally> w3c/
Lagally: got responses from wide review groups
I18n
i18n-activity issue 1664 - [WoT Profile] Unclear character set constraints and non-UTF-8 html
Kaz: any questions about the response?
Lagally: so far the response is clear enough
… why don't we invite them to the Profile call next Thursday?
… how to invite them?
Kaz: you as the Profile TF moderator can send an invitation message to them (Addison an Atsushi) CCing team-wot (including McCool, Sebastian and Kaz)
Lagally: OK. will do
wot-profile issue 373 - Mismatch with MUST clause and examples in default language section
Lagally: kind of long discussion bout default language section
… should update the example
<mlagally> w3c/
Kaz: so you want to talk about their issue 1664 and our issue 373 next Thursday. Right?
Lagally: yeah
Privacy
<mlagally> PING issue 115 - Web of Things (WoT) Profile 2023-02-16 > 2023-03-20
Lagally: wait until they file a new issue on wot-profile based on this review
… would be a good idea to invite them too
A11y
A11y issue 54 - Web of Things (WoT) Profile 2023-02-16 > 2023-03-20
Kaz: still waiting for the response. Right?
Lagally: right
… we're waiting for Security and TAG as well
Issues
Issue 34
Issue 34 - Extension vocabulary for protocols
Lagally: can be closed
(closed)
Issue 213
Issue 213 - Wrong place to use HTTP Baseline Profile
Ege: thought there was a related PR
Lagally: ok
… let's close this after handling that
Kaz: Ege, do you have the number of the URL of the related PR handy?
<Ege> PR 297 - Revised Abstract and Introduction - fixes #115
Ege: PR 297 as above
Issue 299
Issue 299 - Contradiction with the Arch spec on protocol bindings
Lagally: what is the actual problem here?
Ege: the problem is clear
… Architecture spec says:
Protocol Bindings MUST be serialized as hypermedia controls to be self-descriptive on how to activate the Interaction Affordance.
Ege: On the other hand, Profile also defines protocol binding
… should make sure the Protocol Binding part
… also all the examples should have complete description of the forms tag
Lagally: what is need then?
… we need to have concrete examples
… you can create your own examples
… (adds comments to the Issue 299)
… need more discussion and a concrete proposal
Ege: note that Lagally's example for the Testfest didn't have problem
Lagally's example TD for the Testfest
Lagally: should remove the normative language from the Architecture spec
… then add language to require "complete forms"
Kaz: which document?
Lagally: requirements for "complete forms" to be included in the Profile spec
Issue 302 - Clarify the payload formats of read/write property
Issue 302
Lagally: let's keep this open
Contributions
PR 374
PR 374 - Define values of in and name for basic security scheme
Lagally: (goes through the changes and comments)
… I'm OK with this PR
Kaz: +1
(merged)
PR 334
PR 334 - WIP: Provide example in the new introduction section
Lagally: marked as "WIP"
… would like to get feedback from Sebastian
… Ege, can you ping him?
Ege: ok
PR 368
<mlagally__> PR 368 - Add TD assertion conformance
Lagally: myself was thinking about simple editorial changes
… but second point need further discussion
… Ben was raising comments
Ege: would require big changes, so would suggest we add exceptions
Lagally: wondering about Ben's 2nd point
One slight subtlety here is that in the HTTP SSE Profile we assume the text/event-stream response type from the subprotocol member of the Form being set to sse. Given this is fixed in the SSE specification, I think that's a reasonable assumption.
Lagally: If we work on the exception, we should look into the spec carefully
… and see if there is anything else missing
Kaz: we should add necessary clarification for the Profile spec
… but should think about the detailed analysis on the relationship among related specs separately (if possible)
PR 297
PR 297 - Revised Abstract and Introduction - fixes #115
Lagally: let's revisit this next time
AOB
Lagally: please review the remaining issues around Profile 1.0 too
[adjourned]