IRC log of silver-conf on 2021-03-18

Timestamps are in UTC.

15:40:24 [RRSAgent]
RRSAgent has joined #silver-conf
15:40:24 [RRSAgent]
logging to https://www.w3.org/2021/03/18-silver-conf-irc
15:40:26 [Zakim]
RRSAgent, make logs Public
15:40:27 [Zakim]
please title this meeting ("meeting: ..."), sajkaj
15:40:55 [sajkaj]
Meeting: Silver Conformance Options Subgroup
15:41:04 [sajkaj]
Date: 18 Mar 2021
15:41:12 [sajkaj]
Chair: Sajkaj
15:41:17 [sajkaj]
agenda?
15:41:25 [sajkaj]
zakim, clear agenda
15:41:25 [Zakim]
agenda cleared
15:41:30 [sajkaj]
Agenda+ Agenda Review & Administrative Items
15:41:30 [sajkaj]
agenda+ Continue work on March Deliverable -- Report on Use Cases
15:41:30 [sajkaj]
agenda+ Assigned github issues https://github.com/w3c/silver/labels/Subgroup%3A%20Conformance%20Options
15:41:33 [sajkaj]
agenda+ Use Cases Discussion (Continued)
15:41:35 [sajkaj]
agenda+ Other Business
15:41:38 [sajkaj]
agenda+ Be Done
15:59:36 [Azlan]
Azlan has joined #silver-conf
16:00:17 [PeterKorn]
PeterKorn has joined #silver-conf
16:01:58 [Todd]
Todd has joined #silver-conf
16:01:58 [sajkaj]
present+Regrets: Jemma
16:02:08 [Azlan]
present+
16:02:12 [sajkaj]
present+
16:02:14 [PeterKorn]
present+
16:03:09 [JF]
JF has joined #silver-conf
16:03:14 [JF]
Present+
16:03:20 [JF]
agenda?
16:03:48 [Jemma]
regret+
16:04:45 [sajkaj]
scribe: Todd:
16:05:06 [Todd]
present+
16:05:56 [sajkaj]
zakim, next item
16:05:56 [Zakim]
agendum 1 -- Agenda Review & Administrative Items -- taken up [from sajkaj]
16:07:36 [PeterKorn]
q+
16:07:38 [Todd]
sajkaj: look through agenda but not enough to be present to pass
16:07:51 [bruce_bailey]
bruce_bailey has joined #silver-conf
16:08:16 [Todd]
sajkaj: useful comments to look at from github
16:08:50 [sajkaj]
q?
16:09:01 [bruce_bailey]
present+
16:09:14 [PeterKorn]
ack Az
16:09:21 [PeterKorn]
ask jea
16:09:24 [sajkaj]
ack Azlan
16:09:32 [sajkaj]
q/
16:09:34 [sajkaj]
q?
16:09:51 [sajkaj]
ack Jea
16:09:56 [sajkaj]
ack PeterKorn
16:10:09 [Todd]
PeterKorn: would explain what was done earlier this week and deliver report in March to Silver
16:10:09 [sajkaj]
zakim, next item
16:10:09 [Zakim]
agendum 2 -- Continue work on March Deliverable -- Report on Use Cases -- taken up [from sajkaj]
16:10:57 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Deliver report in March of use cases to Silver. Put use cases into 4 "buckets"
16:11:12 [Wilco_]
Wilco_ has joined #silver-conf
16:11:40 [Wilco_]
present+
16:12:03 [sajkaj]
q?
16:12:47 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Collection of use cases that need deeper discussion.
16:13:10 [sajkaj]
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1GyUYTnZp0HIMdsKqCiISCSCvL0su692dnW34P81kbbw/
16:14:09 [sajkaj]
q?
16:14:26 [jeanne]
jeanne has joined #silver-conf
16:14:38 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Scoring with letters, scoring use cases in Google Doc (link above)
16:15:32 [sajkaj]
q?
16:16:30 [sajkaj]
q?
16:17:13 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Reiterated what buckets are about again.
16:18:43 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Focused on problem areas not on existing areas - Bucket 1
16:18:55 [sajkaj]
q?
16:19:44 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Covered by FPWD structure, but needs to be handled in to-be-written guideline - Bucket 2
16:20:37 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Went over use cases in Bucket 2.
16:20:50 [sajkaj]
q?
16:22:50 [Todd]
Group giving some deliberation time. 8 days still remain until report is due.
16:23:55 [sajkaj]
q?
16:24:11 [Todd]
jeanne: asking Wilco_ what aspect is not covered.
16:24:31 [Todd]
Wilco_: could have score that falls below the threshhold
16:26:07 [JF]
Q+
16:26:52 [sajkaj]
q?
16:26:56 [sajkaj]
ack jf
16:26:57 [PeterKorn]
ack JF
16:27:48 [Todd]
JF: Speaking on time component
16:28:48 [sajkaj]
q?
16:32:59 [JF]
Q+
16:33:30 [sajkaj]
q?
16:33:34 [sajkaj]
ack jf
16:34:12 [Todd]
JF: Can't make broad predictions about users re: Whoville widget.
16:34:55 [PeterKorn]
q+
16:35:10 [sajkaj]
ack p
16:36:15 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Suggestions, whether it could be covered with a guideline that is disgreed or outside guideline.
16:36:34 [sajkaj]
q?
16:38:11 [jeanne]
q+ to read the definition of the critical errors
16:38:32 [Todd]
JF: touching on impact of classification/prioritization/criticality
16:38:32 [sajkaj]
q?
16:38:53 [sajkaj]
ack jeanne
16:38:53 [Zakim]
jeanne, you wanted to read the definition of the critical errors
16:39:40 [JF]
Q+
16:39:45 [Todd]
jeanne: discussing definition of critical error
16:40:17 [Wilco_]
+1
16:40:22 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Put 3A into Bucket 4
16:41:30 [sajkaj]
q?
16:41:43 [sajkaj]
ack jf
16:44:49 [sajkaj]
q?
16:45:57 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Bucket 3 - 4 items proposed to be placed in bucket.
16:46:37 [Todd]
Bucket 3, not covered that we see.
16:46:51 [sajkaj]
q?
16:48:32 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Bucket 4, Whoville item and to be discussed use cases.
16:49:58 [sajkaj]
q?
16:50:29 [Todd]
q+
16:51:34 [sajkaj]
scribe: sajkaj
16:51:43 [Wilco_]
q+
16:52:01 [sajkaj]
Todd: : Wonders whether Errors SG should look at Detlev's use case?
16:52:38 [sajkaj]
Todd: : Offers to check with Sarah and report back
16:53:10 [sajkaj]
PeterKorn: : Suggests bucket 4 with note about request to Errors SG? Objections?
16:53:14 [sajkaj]
[crickets]
16:54:04 [sajkaj]
scribe: Tod
16:54:09 [sajkaj]
ack tod
16:54:16 [sajkaj]
ack Wilco_
16:54:23 [Todd]
Wilco_: ask about potential use cases
16:55:41 [sajkaj]
zakim, take up item 4
16:55:41 [Zakim]
agendum 4 -- Use Cases Discussion (Continued) -- taken up [from sajkaj]
16:57:45 [Todd]
Wilco_: 3rd party components discussed, what fits into category
17:00:17 [Todd]
JF: discussion on whether CRM is involved in 3rd party
17:00:29 [Todd]
discussion between CRM vs. CMS (WordPress)
17:00:52 [Todd]
What end of the spectrum those are on if not near or with each other
17:02:16 [Todd]
PeterKorn: Agreed on new 3rd party principle that Wilco's use case goes into
17:03:38 [Todd]
Todd has left #silver-conf
17:03:43 [Azlan]
Bye all
17:03:47 [Azlan]
Azlan has left #silver-conf
17:04:14 [sajkaj]
rrsagent, make minutes
17:04:14 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/03/18-silver-conf-minutes.html sajkaj
17:05:03 [sajkaj]
zakim, end meeting
17:05:03 [Zakim]
As of this point the attendees have been ToddLibby, Azlan, JF, sarahhorton, John_Northup, PeterKorn, jeanne, sajkaj, Regrets:, Jemma, Todd, bruce_bailey, Wilco_
17:05:06 [Zakim]
RRSAgent, please draft minutes
17:05:06 [RRSAgent]
I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/03/18-silver-conf-minutes.html Zakim
17:05:08 [Zakim]
I am happy to have been of service, sajkaj; please remember to excuse RRSAgent. Goodbye
17:05:13 [Zakim]
Zakim has left #silver-conf
17:53:33 [sajkaj]
zakim, clear agenda
17:53:56 [sajkaj]
rrsagent, bye
17:53:56 [RRSAgent]
I see no action items