16:02:10 <RRSAgent> RRSAgent has joined #voiceinteraction
16:02:10 <RRSAgent> logging to https://www.w3.org/2021/02/24-voiceinteraction-irc
16:02:47 <dirk> dirk has joined #voiceinteraction
16:04:47 <BC> BC has joined #voiceinteraction
16:04:56 <BC> Hello
16:05:06 <ddahl> chair:debbie
16:05:22 <ddahl> meeting: voice interaction
16:05:26 <ddahl> scribe: ddahl
16:07:44 <ddahl> topic: review Debbie's updates
16:07:56 <ddahl> https://github.com/w3c/voiceinteraction/commit/cd5aefa00cee887583e89d5aedc3158057224548
16:09:53 <ddahl> dirk: should say something about input and output of NLG, can make use of the context to determine best form of output
16:11:15 <ddahl> debbie: anything about "dialog"?
16:13:08 <ddahl> debbie: change "support" to "supply"
16:18:46 <ddahl> present: debbie, bev, jimLarson,jon,dirk
16:19:20 <ddahl> debbie: we'll talk about publishing next time (March 10)
16:22:44 <ddahl> debbie: brief definition of "data provider"
16:23:17 <ddahl> jim: examples of data providers?
16:24:15 <ddahl> dirk: could be a bank, temperature sensor, IoT thing
16:24:40 <ddahl> ...we should add examples of data providers
16:24:54 <ddahl> bev: could be added to the use case
16:25:30 <ddahl> dirk: we could add that to the use case
16:26:17 <ddahl> debbie: external services
16:26:48 <ddahl> debbie: how is that different from a data provider?
16:27:16 <ddahl> dirk: it's a subset of data providers
16:27:42 <ddahl> jim: could make a change in the world, like send something to printer
16:30:52 <BC> relying parties too
16:31:53 <ddahl> debbie: IPA providers
16:32:57 <ddahl> debbie: external service, broader than data
16:33:21 <ddahl> dirk: sevices also executing
16:33:30 <ddahl> s/sevices/services
16:33:48 <ddahl> bev: are users included, or just services?
16:33:58 <BC> Users?
16:34:45 <ddahl> debbie: I think users are more at the beginning of the interaction
16:35:08 <ddahl> debbie: back to IPA providers
16:35:21 <BC> Ok
16:36:25 <ddahl> bev: need to make sure we define IPA's
16:37:04 <ddahl> dirk: IPA's that could forward requests to another IPA
16:38:09 <ddahl> dirk: request could be forwarded to Alexa
16:38:21 <ddahl> jon: or from Alexa to your bank
16:39:07 <ddahl> dirk: forwarding requests has been covered
16:39:31 <ddahl> jon: IPA's enable interactions by users
16:39:59 <BC> @jon +1
16:40:21 <ddahl> debbie: we should add acknowledgements before publishing
16:41:35 <ddahl> action: debbie to make editorial changes that we've discussed
16:43:19 <ddahl> action: jon, jim, bev to read and comment by March 8
16:44:22 <ddahl> debbie: then return to interfaces document, JSON version of EMMA
16:45:28 <ddahl> debbie: try to align ideas with OVN, since there is overlap?
16:45:59 <ddahl> jim: have whiteboard session to get together and chat about common ideas
16:46:09 <ddahl> ...on Tuesdays
16:46:38 <ddahl> jon: could also be on another session or larger workshop
16:48:06 <ddahl> debbie: should focus on problems, not specific architectures
16:48:34 <ddahl> jon: there are two or three big questions -- e.g. how is a dialog shared between agents
16:49:23 <ddahl> jon: focus on one-two questions
16:49:49 <ddahl> jim: W3C seminar on how to voice applications work together
16:53:04 <ddahl> jim: focused W3C-like seminar, more whiteboard talks, visit to OVN regular meeting
16:53:47 <ddahl> debbie: start with whiteboard?
16:54:35 <ddahl> jon: jim and I will work offline
16:55:30 <ddahl> jim: what will happen after this document is published?
16:55:48 <ddahl> dirk: would like to see it reflected in IPA implementations
16:56:24 <ddahl> jim: this is meant to be an inspiration to developers
16:58:32 <ddahl> ... we can give presentations, etc.
16:59:08 <ddahl> bev: information architecture community group
16:59:36 <ddahl> ...several members are interested in helping
17:00:43 <ddahl> debbie: they could just join voice interaction
17:01:22 <ddahl> ...bev can post to IA group
17:02:26 <BC> Thank you
17:04:14 <ddahl> debbie: link to the architecture document https://w3c.github.io/voiceinteraction/voice%20interaction%20drafts/paArchitecture-1-1.htm
17:04:25 <ddahl> rrsagent, format minutes
17:04:25 <RRSAgent> I have made the request to generate https://www.w3.org/2021/02/24-voiceinteraction-minutes.html ddahl
17:04:32 <ddahl> rrsagent, make logs public
18:31:53 <ddahl> ddahl has left #voiceinteraction