<kaz> scribenick: elena_
McCool: any quick updates?
noone raised any
McCool: any meeting minutes from last time to review?
<kaz> https://www.w3.org/2019/10/14-wot-sec-minutes.html
<kaz> https://www.w3.org/2019/10/21-wot-sec-minutes.html
<McCool> https://www.w3.org/2019/09/09-wot-sec-minutes.html
minutes from september 9th are already approved
McCool: 14th of October minutes
looking through, no changes from my side
... any objections to accept minutes?
no objections
14th of October is accepted
McCool: 20th of october: any objections to accepting the minutes?
no objections
both meeting minutes are accepted
McCool: time choice
discussion
... current slot is not optimal for everyone is it is 3am time
for Canada, which does not work for me
... so we discussing to go back to our previous time on
Monday
... elena will resolve the problem and we can go back to slot
9pm on Japan time
... does anyone has objections to the 9pm slot on Monday for
security call?
no objections raised
McCool: starting next week we have a call on Mondays at 10pm Japan time
<kaz> ACTION: kaz to allocate a new webex for wot-security on Monday at 8an EST (10pm JST)
McCool: next publication status.
Kaz: there are still several
minor errors
... PR from Michael is merged
<kaz> Master branch Editor's draft
<kaz> updated Note3 version generated from the Master branch Editor's draft
<kaz> Pubrules checker results
McCool: let's look at the current state
Kaz: current master version has several errors with the Pubruels Checker, needs fixing
McCool: changes that I did
recently - deleted summary and added change log
... in changelog I talk about name change and made summary for
all the diffs, including from second and first version
... also made few minor tweaks
... changed to use references for WoT Architecture and WoT TD
from hyperlinks
Kaz: need to fix errors including
these references
... we should check the pubrules checker results
looking at errors
3 errors displayed
<kaz> Pubrules results again
also looking at the warnings
McCool: let's fix the errors
Kaz: given that both WoT Architecture and WoT TD refer to WoT Security and Privacy Guidelines, the latter one should be either published first or on the same day
McCool: let's do the mandatory
fixes now
... they should be easy fixes
McCool is actually doing fixes
McCool: is best practice document published?
Kaz: no, and it is ok to refer to it by URL
McCool fixing duplicate id referral
McCool commits the changes to master branch
McCool: kaz should get it
finalized and published now
... we need to clean up Editors notes in the doc also
<kaz> [the draft on the master branch has been updated :) ]
McCool: looking at the EN on
Links
... associated with the dereferencing risk
... section on privacy needs improvements and updates, also
associated with identifiers
with unique cryptographic identifiers
McCool: let's create an issue for updating this section
<McCool> https://github.com/w3c/wot-security/issues/140
McCool: let's look at issues and
PRs
... we should also cleanup our references
<inserted> PR 137
looking at PR 137
<inserted> Issue 123
McCool: this relates to issue
123
... about mixing gateway and proxy terminology
... we have other places where we use proxy, so we should not
make the change for just this one place, because it adds
inconsistency
... we should just explain that proxy is one of the special
cases of the intermediary
Taki: makes sense
McCool: should we add a sentence now before the final publication is done or do it after?
Kaz: first priority is to publish as soon as possible
McCool: so let's close this PR
for now, but in the future (after publication is done) to add a
sentence explaining proxy terminology
... let's add an issue to record this action
<kaz> new Issue 141 for that
issue 141 created
McCool: we should go and close some old issues
<kaz> Issue 134
looking at issue 134
McCool: any objections to close this issue?
McCool closing it
McCool: we should close the
issues next time
... if new participants, including Oliver could try to go
review the document
Oliver: what is the preferred way of reporting issues?
McCool: if it is typo, just
create PR, if it is a bigger issue, create an issue
... we are out of time, any other business?
... we are proceeding with the publication now
meeting finished
<kaz> [adjourned]