IRC log of coga on 2015-06-22
Timestamps are in UTC.
- 15:18:18 [RRSAgent]
- RRSAgent has joined #coga
- 15:18:18 [RRSAgent]
- logging to http://www.w3.org/2015/06/22-coga-irc
- 15:18:30 [Lisa_Seeman]
- zakim, this will be WAI_CogTF
- 15:18:30 [Zakim]
- I do not see a conference matching that name scheduled within the next hour, Lisa_Seeman
- 15:20:35 [Lisa_Seeman]
- regrets:Chaohai Ding , Ayelet Seeman, Jamie Knight
- 15:21:20 [Lisa_Seeman]
- Chair:Lisa_Seeman
- 15:21:22 [Lisa_Seeman]
- 15:21:23 [Lisa_Seeman]
- agenda: this
- 15:21:25 [Lisa_Seeman]
- agenda+ review actions, and timelines
- 15:21:26 [Lisa_Seeman]
- agenda+ Issue papers - GA
- 15:21:28 [Lisa_Seeman]
- agenda+ Techniques - GA
- 15:21:29 [Lisa_Seeman]
- agenda+ Next ftf ideas (TPAC and Katie suggestion)agenda+ Other issue papers
- 15:21:31 [Lisa_Seeman]
- agenda+ be done
- 15:42:49 [slim]
- slim has joined #coga
- 15:59:56 [JohnRochford]
- JohnRochford has joined #coga
- 16:00:00 [Lisa_Seeman]
- Joined on the call so far: Lisa Michael, John R. EA Steve
- 16:01:16 [Lisa_Seeman]
- next item
- 16:03:12 [slim]
- JohnRochford: remember no body expected the Spanish Inquition
- 16:03:41 [ddahl]
- ddahl has joined #coga
- 16:05:44 [Lisa_Seeman]
- scribe: JohnRochford
- 16:05:57 [Lisa_Seeman]
- https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/cognitive-a11y-tf/wiki/Main_Page
- 16:06:06 [Lisa_Seeman]
- https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/cognitive-a11y-tf/track/actions/open
- 16:10:16 [slim]
- email from Anthony - hopes to join us
- 16:10:29 [richardschwerdtfeger]
- richardschwerdtfeger has joined #coga
- 16:12:03 [JohnRochford]
- EA: We don't know what to do for gap analysis for non-verbal.
- 16:12:22 [janina_]
- present+ janina
- 16:12:45 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: Pinging me on Skype is generally good.
- 16:14:29 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: Techniques in issue paper on Voice XML are for everyone, not just people with cognitive disabilities.
- 16:16:09 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: It sounds to me we are ready to have a conversation about a gap analysis for Voice XML.
- 16:16:56 [ddahl]
- the gap analysis for voice UI's indicates that the problem is adoption
- 16:17:07 [JohnRochford]
- janina: I'm ready for a conversation about issue paper on Web of Things.
- 16:18:37 [slim]
- User Preferences, Adaptable Links and Buttons Personalization, adapting content for coga personalization
- 16:18:41 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: Steve has said he has taken on too much. I will write to the list to ask people to help.
- 16:19:04 [ea]
- ea has joined #coga
- 16:19:40 [Lisa_Seeman]
- https://rawgit.com/w3c/coga/master/issue-papers/voice-menus.html
- 16:20:22 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: Link is to Voice XML issue paper.
- 16:20:49 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: Let's now review that issue paper.
- 16:21:20 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: There is no digit that requests a human.
- 16:22:07 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: It would be good to have a reserved word to get through to a human.
- 16:22:58 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: Some systems would resist using a reserved word, or certain words.
- 16:23:49 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: Whole industry is moving away from command-based interfaces. Are now trying to make them more natural.
- 16:24:40 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: It's common to use zero to get to a person.
- 16:25:12 [JohnRochford]
- EA: It's important there is a button that can be pressed, especially for non-verbal users.
- 16:26:27 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: Perhaps, rather than zero, the button should be the hash tag or the star.
- 16:27:06 [JohnRochford]
- Steve: Stars seem to have disappeared from Voice XML systems.
- 16:27:29 [JohnRochford]
- EA: Another issue is localization.
- 16:28:12 [JohnRochford]
- EA: What's most important is alerting, especially for emergencies.
- 16:28:50 [Tony_Doran]
- Tony_Doran has joined #coga
- 16:28:59 [JohnRochford]
- janina: Whatever is set up, someone won't be able to use it, so there must be a fallback.
- 16:29:10 [ea]
- I agree with Janina
- 16:30:46 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: Not all systems are designed to have a human backup.
- 16:31:32 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: Perhaps there should be a requirement for a human backup.
- 16:32:46 [JohnRochford]
- janina: If your phone is old enough, the zero is probably marked with "operator".
- 16:33:40 [JohnRochford]
- janina: That legacy may mean zero should be the digit that requests a human.
- 16:33:41 [Lisa_Seeman]
- q?
- 16:34:55 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: Websites too should have a way to reach a human.
- 16:35:15 [JohnRochford]
- janina: Increasingly, in that regard, there are chat clients.
- 16:35:22 [neilislateagain]
- neilislateagain has joined #coga
- 16:35:34 [JohnRochford]
- correction: chat forums
- 16:36:51 [JohnRochford]
- janina: Having a human backup may be resisted because it would be admitting a system could fail.
- 16:37:48 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: Resistance can also be due to the expense incurred by having a human backup.
- 16:39:01 [neilislateagain]
- I agree the resistance is more usually financial
- 16:39:39 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: The number of menu choices should be 3 to 4 for everyone, not just COGA users, and the option for repeating the menu should be a standard.
- 16:40:17 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: A standard for menu repeating should be added to the issue paper.
- 16:40:39 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: We do want to add that we want to standardize on zero.
- 16:41:51 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: Perhaps there should be a standard that repeated failures should invoke a menu with longer but more-clearly explained choices.
- 16:42:34 [JohnRochford]
- * ddahl: Another possible standard may be that no user response invokes a human backup.
- 16:45:51 [JohnRochford]
- Rich: WCAG may be our best strategy because of the upcoming 508 refresh in the U.S. regarding establishing best practices for Voice XML.
- 16:46:18 [JohnRochford]
- Rich: egarding establishing best practices for Voice XML.
- 16:46:36 [JohnRochford]
- John says "ugh".
- 16:47:10 [JohnRochford]
- Rich: Regarding establishing best practices for Voice XML, WCAG may be our best strategy because of the upcoming 508 refresh in the U.S.
- 16:48:54 [Lisa_Seeman]
- https://www.w3.org/WAI/PF/cognitive-a11y-tf/wiki/Gap_Analysis
- 16:49:11 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: I could raise, in the voice browser group, the issue of introducing a note, from the PF group, about our proposed best practices / standards for Voice XML.
- 16:50:23 [JohnRochford]
- ddahl: There is a big community of Voice XML usability experts that may have a different idea from using zero to get a human.
- 16:50:50 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: They can say what they like and don't like about it.
- 16:52:43 [Lisa_Seeman]
- https://rawgit.com/w3c/coga/master/issue-papers/wot.html
- 16:52:46 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: Janina will now talk about the Internet of Things.
- 16:54:36 [ea]
- did they make any decision about whether the internet of things is the same as the web of things?
- 16:54:54 [JohnRochford]
- janina: There is nothing unique about the Internet of Things. It's about the UI.
- 16:55:55 [JohnRochford]
- janina: I don't see that we have identified anything that is unique about the IoT.
- 16:58:02 [JohnRochford]
- Lisa: We should include Tim, the author of our IoT issue paper, in this discussion.
- 17:01:05 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2015/06/22-coga-minutes.html MichaelC
- 17:01:55 [MichaelC]
- present: Tony_Doran, John_Rochford, Steve_Lee, Rich_Schwerdtfeger, Neil_Milliken, Lisa_Seeman, Janina_Sajka, EA_Draffan, Debbie_Dahl, Michael_Cooper
- 17:02:02 [ea]
- yes that was my concern - the confusion between the two and the debate that is going on about WoT and IoT From the Internet of Things to the Web of Things: Resource Oriented Architecture and Best Practices1 Dominique Guinard1,2, Vlad Trifa1,2, Friedemann Mattern1 , Erik Wilde3
- 17:02:03 [MichaelC]
- rrsagent, make log world
- 17:02:24 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2015/06/22-coga-minutes.html MichaelC
- 18:34:38 [MichaelC]
- topic: Cognitive and Learning Disabilities Accessibility Task Force
- 18:34:44 [MichaelC]
- scribeOptions: -final
- 18:34:58 [RRSAgent]
- I have made the request to generate http://www.w3.org/2015/06/22-coga-minutes.html MichaelC
- 18:35:03 [MichaelC]
- rrsagent, bye
- 18:35:03 [RRSAgent]
- I see no action items