[done] accessible home page - "news highlights images" (brains, giant hat, violin) are decorative and should not have any alt-text Resolution: accept and fix; explain in annotation that this is an author-decision and outline that other options exist too
[done] accessible news page - alt-text for "baby" image is repetitive and does not add any information Resolution: partially accepted: removed redundant "15 months" information because it is not relevant to the image but kept "Clara F." as it is a useful label for the image
[done] accessible news page - use the word "photo" rather than "foto" Resolution: typo was only in the annotations planning page and has been removed
[done] accessible news page - make sure that the annotation for the reading order highlights the correct area Resolution: revisit after the annotations have been populated
[done] accessible news page - "zoo keeper" image has more detail in the alt-attribute than the image may convey to most readers Resolution: changed from "Zookeeper on holidays in Katoomba (Australia) posing in front of the famous 3 sisters rock outcrop" to "Zookeeper off work, posing in front of a canyon and enjoying the warm sun" Note: the purpose is to show descriptive alt-text where appropriate
[done] accessible tickets page - remove centering from "terms and conditions" heading Resolution: removed and added to inaccessible tickets page instead
[done] accessible survey page - remove "---->" from the pull-down menu Resolution: accept and fix
[done] re-open issues #15, #16, and #17 from below Action: re-opened and addressed accordingly
[done] overview page - add something suggestive of how to best use this resource Resolution: consider improving current wording in the final editorial pass
[done] all demo pages - annotations are not immediatley apparent Resolution: wait until all annotations are added and re-visit issue -- need to check during public review
[done] all demo pages - unlcear if all pages have annotations Resolution: wait until all annotations are added and re-visit issue
[done] all demo pages - skip link: does not work in Chrome Resolution: work-around for this issue is more confusing than helpful for demo users
[done] accessible news page - add data table as alternative for the "brain donations" graph Resolution: not necessary for this simple table; add information about different solutions in the annotation text
[done] accessible home page - skipnav: increase the line-height slighly for better readability Resolution: accept and fix
[done] accessible home page - access-toggle: do not "abuse" the » for a visual element, consider a background image Resolution: accept and fix
[done] accessible home page - the hidden "copyright notice" label in the footer is kind of redundant information Resolution: accept and remove
[done] accessible home page - while zooming (text only) the h2 needs a clear to the left Resolution: accept and fix
[done] accessible home page - while zooming (text only) the tab-navigation gets disconnected from the demo-page below. this is due to the #mnav a, #mnav .current { ... height: 20px ...} Resolution: accept and fix
[done] accessible home page - annotations: add the word technique (at least in the title-attribute) for every technique link, as it might not be clear for everybody that H37 is not a secret accessibility code ... Resolution: accept and fix
[done] accessible home page - annotations: the html-elements and attributes are not consistently marked up within CODE-elements Resolution: dummy text current, will be fixed when real annotations are added
[done] accessible home page - annotations: why did you decide to clone the annotations instead of just temporarily changing the style to bring them in foreground? Resolution: explain rationale and check with commenter
[done] accessible survey page - shouldn't we indicate the required fields in advance. the note which are required comes after submitting the form Resolution: Add text "required if not otherwise noted"
[done] accessible survey page - HTML-Error: even more errors after form processing Resolution: verify and fix
[done] accessible survey page - after submission: style for the error summary needs a little enclosing, maybe a border around the whole error block Resolution: accept and fix
[done] accessible survey page - after submission: indicate the required fields with an asterisk in any case at the end of the label and with the visible wording "required" in red if the input was missing Resolution: accept and check for wording
[done] accessible survey page - consider summary in the table of the survey page Resolution: no summary needed for this simple table; explain in the annotations Note: empty summary attribute has been removed
[done] accessible tickets page - concert dates table: check need for the summary attribute Resolution: no summary needed for this simple table; explain in the annotations Note: summary attribute has been removed
[done] accessible tickets page - seat allocation table: check need for the summary attribute Resolution: accept, check for appropriate summary text Note: summary attribute and caption have been modified
[done] accessible site - check use of the summary attribute on the tables throughout Resolution: re-check after the annotations are added
[done] all demo pages - "quick menu": should the menu lead to pages on the same site (News, Tickets, Survey, etc)? Resolution: make all quick menu links lead to a dummy "catch 'em all" page that explains that this is a demo site
[done] accessible site - "quick menu": links to do not go to Wikipedia but back to the same page (check for bug) Resolution: accept and fix redirect script (now redirects to "catch 'em all" page, see issue #11 above)
[done] all demo pages - does linking to external (sometimes inaccessible) resources imply endorsement from WAI? Resolution: reject endorsment argument but implement "catch 'em all" as in resolution #11 for consistency
[done] accessible survey page - optional newsletter: directions are unclear, consider saying "if you want to receive a newsletter ..." so that users don't expect yes/no input Resolution: rename text to say "To receive ..." as per Eric's suggestion
[done] accessible survey page - optional newsletter: the first set of radio buttons should be grouped as "Title" Resolution: reject since the nesting would likely add more noise than use
[done] accessible survey page - optional newsletter: label "name" should be placed adjecent to the input field Resolution: accepted to demonstrate best practice
[done] accessible survey page - optional newsletter: "eMail Address" and "Retype eMail" labels should be placed above the input fields Resolution: accepted to demonstrate best practice
[done] all demo pages - tabs: consider adding more spaces to separate the "Template" tab visually Resolution: reject since top navigation is for the demo, not for the site
[done] overview page - explain what "annotations" are Resolution: add a description of annotations to the wrapper pages
[done] barriers page - explain that these are only highlights of some of the main issues Resolution: "barriers page" has been discontinued in favor of "in-between" annotated pages
[done] accessible site - "quick menu": check use of title attribute and value of the submit button Resolution: remove title attribute from the submit button
[done] accessible home page - title: make title more precise, describe the current location "home page" Resolution: rename title to "Citylights Home - your access to the city"
[done] accessible home page - "take survey" link: is not apparent from the surrounding text Resolution: rename teaser headings to "Citylights Concert" and "Citylights Survey" or similar
[done] accessible survey page - submit buttons on the "quick menu" and the survey form have the same labels Resolution: covered by the resolution for comment #3
[done] accessible survey page - check the e-mail validity script for possible bug Resolution: dot before @ fails; update the checking script
[done] accessible survey page - after submission: consider adding a reminder that the submission of the form is fictional Resolution: add a sentence in the feedback to remind people that the newsletter is fictional
[done] accessible survey page - after submission: consider reflecting the status of submission in the page title Resolution: add a brief statement about the status in the title of the survey page, like "Citylights Survey - successful submission" or similar