XML Protocol
2 November 2005
Agenda
See also:IRC log
Attendees
- Present
- BEA Systems, David Orchard
- Canon, Herve Ruellan
- IBM, Chris Ferris
- Iona Technologies, Suresh Kodichath
- Nokia, Mike Mahan
- Oracle, Anish Karmarkar
- Sun Microsystems,Marc Hadley
- SeeBeyond (Sun Microsystems), Pete Wenzel
- W3C, Yves Lafon
- Regrets
- IBM, Noah Mendelsohn
- Absent
- Microsoft Corporation, Mike Vernal
- SAP AG, Volker Wiechers
- Excused
- BEA Systems, Mark Nottingham
- Canon, Jean-Jacques Moreau
- Microsoft Corporation, Doug Purdy
- Oracle, Jeff Mischkinsky
- Sun Microsystems, Tony Graham
- Chair
- Mike Mahan
- Scribe
- Suresh Kodichath
2. Agenda review, scheduling and AOB
- MikeM: F2F at TP, challenging to schedule.
-
- Options are day / half-day on thursday, or convince one extra
day and do it on sat..
- Members prefer meeting at TP rather than one another seperate
meeting considering another travel arrangement...
- Yves: first pref, orgnanize after TP.
- DavidO: weekend, either before or after
- Chris: slightly for after
- Anish: before, but no big pref.
- Chris: will check with Noah
- Suresh: won't be attending, will check IONA representative at
TP will be able to attend
- ACTION: Mike to ask the coordinator to schedule a room forthe
saturday after the TP
3. Approval of minutes
- MikeM: Minutes of 12 Oct. approved
- MikeM: Minutes of 19 Oct. approved
4. Action Items:
http://www.w3.org/2000/xp/Group/Admin/#pending
- ------
- MikeM: Review appendix K and/or L from Voice Browser
- CLOSED
- ------
- Anish: Respond to his xmlp-comments posting, copying WSA,
with
- early word of likely disposition of optional response in the
HTTP binding
- Anish has dependency on Mark, but will go ahead and do it
- PENDING
- ------
- Yves: Create formal issue for optional response in the HTTP
binding
- DONE
- ------
- Yves: Track W3C's logistics planning for the TP
- DONE
- ------
- Herve: Incorporate rec34/35/36 resolution in the errata
- DONE
- ------
- Yves: Respond to MarkB wrt rec33
- Responded, didn't yet receive any feedback from him, response
is on distapp
- ------
- MikeM: Ask MarkN to take a look at rec33 proposal
- DONE
- ------
- Editors: Summarize on email the discussion they had f2f.
Editors to
- prepare a status for next week. Prefer this to first written up
as
- a set of proposal(s) with pros and cons and sent to
dist-app
- DONE
5. Charter discussion
- Yves: email sent on this last week to the group.
- ACTION: Yves to start the rechartering process
6. SOAP 1.2 PER specs
- 33rec
- MikeM: closing in on resolving 33rec.. using solution presented
by Yves.
- comments from MarkN, it is fine with him.
- Yves: MarkN was in sync. with Mark Baker. Nobody against the
new proposal
- On IRC: Yves:
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/xml-dist-app/2005Oct/0005.html
- Yves:
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/xml-dist-app/2005Oct/0010.html
- Yves: and Mark's reply at
-
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/xml-dist-app/2005Oct/0009.html
- MikeM: Noah wanted an opportunity to talk about this
- Chris: Hasn't talked on this with Noah
- ACTION: Chris to get IBM's position wrt rec33
- -----
- Test Collection Bugs
- Anish: email sent on this 3 weeks ago
- Yves talks about T38 test
- ACTION: Yves to add the test collection issues to the issue
list
- -------
- ACTION: Mike to verify the status of issues wrt PER specs
7. New SOAP MEP/Binding work item
- Chris briefs the WG about the editors different
approaches.
-
- discussions concerning uber-MEP and optional input-ouput
messages MEP. Explains possible approaches (also at
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/xml-dist-app/2005Oct/att-0011/00-part)
-
- wsa:replyTo with non-anonymous URI has issues in uber MEP.
-
- consensus not yet reached on the approaches within the editors,
so will put them to the larger WG.
- Anish: there are similarities between the 2 approaches, but
prefer binding specific thing which chris propose
- DavidO: Prefer binding independent approach.in the theme of the
SOAP1.2 binding - using properties to map and bridge to WSDL
-
- I've sent to the xmlp list but it's not in the archive
yet,
-
- an sap/oracle/ibm approach for ws-addressing to deal with async
-
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-ws-addressing/2005Oct/att0116/ProposalTake3.htm
- Chris: I would encourage people to review the SOAP binding for
BEEP
New Actions
- ACTION: Mike to ask the coordinator to schedule a room forthe
saturday after the TP
- ACTION: Yves to start the rechartering process
- ACTION: Chris to get IBM's position wrt rec33
- ACTION: Yves to add the test collection issues to the issue
list
- ACTION: Mike to verify the status
of issues wrt PER specs