W3C

XML Protocol

2 November 2005

Agenda

See also:IRC log

Attendees

Present
BEA Systems, David Orchard
Canon, Herve Ruellan
IBM, Chris Ferris
Iona Technologies, Suresh Kodichath
Nokia, Mike Mahan
Oracle, Anish Karmarkar
Sun Microsystems,Marc Hadley
SeeBeyond (Sun Microsystems), Pete Wenzel
W3C, Yves Lafon
Regrets
IBM, Noah Mendelsohn

Absent
Microsoft Corporation, Mike Vernal
SAP AG, Volker Wiechers
Excused
BEA Systems, Mark Nottingham
Canon, Jean-Jacques Moreau
Microsoft Corporation, Doug Purdy
Oracle, Jeff Mischkinsky
Sun Microsystems, Tony Graham
Chair
Mike Mahan
Scribe
Suresh Kodichath


2. Agenda review, scheduling and AOB

MikeM: F2F at TP, challenging to schedule.
Members prefer meeting at TP rather than one another seperate meeting considering another travel arrangement...
Yves: first pref, orgnanize after TP.
DavidO: weekend, either before or after
Chris: slightly for after
Anish: before, but no big pref.
Chris: will check with Noah
Suresh: won't be attending, will check IONA representative at TP will be able to attend
ACTION: Mike to ask the coordinator to schedule a room forthe saturday after the TP

3. Approval of minutes

MikeM: Minutes of 12 Oct. approved
MikeM: Minutes of 19 Oct. approved

4. Action Items: http://www.w3.org/2000/xp/Group/Admin/#pending

------
MikeM: Review appendix K and/or L from Voice Browser
CLOSED
------
Anish: Respond to his xmlp-comments posting, copying WSA, with
early word of likely disposition of optional response in the HTTP binding
Anish has dependency on Mark, but will go ahead and do it
PENDING
------
Yves: Create formal issue for optional response in the HTTP binding
DONE
------
Yves: Track W3C's logistics planning for the TP
DONE
------
Herve: Incorporate rec34/35/36 resolution in the errata
DONE
------
Yves: Respond to MarkB wrt rec33
Responded, didn't yet receive any feedback from him, response is on distapp
------
MikeM: Ask MarkN to take a look at rec33 proposal
DONE
------
Editors: Summarize on email the discussion they had f2f. Editors to
prepare a status for next week. Prefer this to first written up as
a set of proposal(s) with pros and cons and sent to dist-app
DONE

5. Charter discussion

Yves: email sent on this last week to the group.
ACTION: Yves to start the rechartering process

6. SOAP 1.2 PER specs


33rec
MikeM: closing in on resolving 33rec.. using solution presented by Yves.
comments from MarkN, it is fine with him.
Yves: MarkN was in sync. with Mark Baker. Nobody against the new proposal
On IRC: Yves: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/xml-dist-app/2005Oct/0005.html
Yves: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/xml-dist-app/2005Oct/0010.html
Yves: and Mark's reply at
http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/xml-dist-app/2005Oct/0009.html
MikeM: Noah wanted an opportunity to talk about this
Chris: Hasn't talked on this with Noah
ACTION: Chris to get IBM's position wrt rec33
-----
Test Collection Bugs
Anish: email sent on this 3 weeks ago
Yves talks about T38 test
ACTION: Yves to add the test collection issues to the issue list
-------
ACTION: Mike to verify the status of issues wrt PER specs

7. New SOAP MEP/Binding work item

Chris briefs the WG about the editors different approaches.
Anish: there are similarities between the 2 approaches, but prefer binding specific thing which chris propose
DavidO: Prefer binding independent approach.in the theme of the SOAP1.2 binding - using properties to map and bridge to WSDL
Chris: I would encourage people to review the SOAP binding for BEEP

New Actions

ACTION: Mike to ask the coordinator to schedule a room forthe saturday after the TP
ACTION: Yves to start the rechartering process
ACTION: Chris to get IBM's position wrt rec33
ACTION: Yves to add the test collection issues to the issue list
ACTION: Mike to verify the status of issues wrt PER specs